Scary Savannah and Beyond
Scary Savannah and Beyond is a podcast featuring paranormal, true crime, and stories of oddities from Savannah, Georgia and beyond. Podcasting from the most haunted city in America!
Episodes
Tybee Island Gets Weird - Meth Pickup Lines and a Frog on the Run - Tybee Police Blotter July 2025
Join Brett and Crystal on Scary Savannah and Beyond as they dive into the July 2025 Tybee Island Police Blotter, packed with wild small-town crime and comedy. From DUI arrests and mysterious marijuana “wafting” cases to suspicious teens wit…
Nightmare on Peachtree - The Winecoff Hotel Fire, Atlanta Georgia
In this chilling episode of Scary Savannah and Beyond, Crystal and Brett uncover the haunting history of Atlanta’s Ellis Hotel, site of the 1946 Winecoff Hotel fire—the deadliest hotel fire in U.S. history, claiming 119 lives. Once touted a…
Wafting, Warrants and WTF - Tybee Island Police Blotter June 2025
Join Brett and Crystal for a wild ride through Tybee Island’s June 2025 police blotter! From DUIs, hit-and-runs, and beachside mayhem to juveniles jumping off piers and a kitten left in a hot car, this episode is packed with true crime, biz…
Unmasking the 1982 Chicago Tylenol Killer - America's First Product Tampering Panic
In this gripping true crime episode, Crystal and Brett dive into the chilling case of the 1982 Chicago Tylenol murders—a nationwide panic that changed the way we package and trust over-the-counter medicine forever. Explore the tragic string…
Beach Bums, Buckets of Water, and Bad Decisions - Tybee Island Police Blotter May 2025
This week on the Tybee Island Police Blotter, we’re diving into the wildest and weirdest crimes from May 2025—including a naked man wandering Butler Avenue, public drunkenness, paddleboard theft, and multiple bizarre DUI arrests (one involv…
Stolen Baby Jesus Surfboard on Tybee? Tybee Island Police Blotter - Small Town True Crime
Join Brett and Crystal in this hilarious comeback episode of the Island Police Blotter podcast, where they unpack outrageous crime reports from Tybee Island — from stolen surfboards and rogue golf carts to marijuana mishaps and wild nursing…
Tybee Island Police Blotter 3/1/25-3/31/25 Updates From Savannah's Beach
In this week’s bonus episode, we’re going back to the Tybee Island Police Blotter to talk about some of the crazy things that go on on the island right outside of Savannah, Georgia. We’re using a new studio setup this week, and it’s wild. A…
The Philadelphia Experiment, A World War 2 Era Mystery
This week we’re talking about the alleged event “The Philadelphia Experiment,” which is said to have happened around October 1943. The USS Eldrige was supposedly testing new government technology that might allow things like time travel and…
Tybee Island Police Blotter 1/1/25-3/1/25 Updates from Savannah's Beach
In this week’s bonus episode, we’re going back to the Tybee Island Police Blotter to talk about some of the crazy things that go on on the island right outside of Savannah, Georgia. After a long delay we’re back - and we’re recapping some o…
Tybee Island Police Blotter 12/31/24-1/12/25 Updates from Savannah's Beach
In this week’s bonus episode, we’re going back to the Tybee Island Police Blotter to talk about some of the crazy things that go on on the island right outside of Savannah, Georgia. Before the show we reveal more information regarding Cynth…
Ghosts of Tybee Island Vol. 1 - The Haunting of Cynthia
We’re back in the New Year with our first regular episode! We haven’t done a paranormal show in a little while, and we’ve always wanted to talk about some of the mysterious ghost stories on our home of little Tybee Island (which is just out…
Tybee Island Police Blotter 9/30/24-12/31/24 Updates from Savannah's Beach
In this week’s bonus episode, we’re going back to the Tybee Island Police Blotter to talk about some of the crazy things that go on on the island right outside of Savannah, Georgia. One of our New Year’s resolutions is to get back to the po…
Tybee Island Police Blotter 9/2/24-9/29/24 Updates from Savannah's Beach
In this week’s bonus episode, we’re going back to the Tybee Island Police Blotter to talk about some of the crazy things that go on on the island right outside of Savannah, Georgia. Lots of guns left in weird places, the usual speeding and …
Tybee Island Police Blotter 8/5/24-9/1/24 Updates from Savannah's Beach
In this week’s bonus episode, we’re going back to the Tybee Island Police Blotter to talk about some of the crazy things that go on on the island right outside of Savannah, Georgia. This week our friend Ethan joins us to talk about the poli…
Halloween 2024 - The Russian Sleep Experiment
This is our 3rd anniversary episode! We’ll do our annual candy sales statistics for Halloween 2024, and there’s a new number one. For this year’s creepy story, Crystal talks about the urban legend “The Russian Sleep Experiment.” Did researc…
Tybee Island Police Blotter 7/22/24-8/4/24 Updates from Savannah's Beach
In this week’s bonus episode, we’re going back to the Tybee Island Police Blotter to talk about some of the crazy things that go on on the island right outside of Savannah, Georgia. There's a lot of bike activity going on this week. Find us…
Tybee Island Police Blotter 6/24/24-7/21/24 Updates from Savannah's Beach
In this week’s bonus episode, we’re going back to the Tybee Island Police Blotter to talk about some of the crazy things that go on on the island right outside of Savannah, Georgia. Some more of your usual craziness as we catch up on severa…
Danny's Bed - A Haunted Tale From Savannah
This week we’re talking about a somewhat obscure Savannah ghost story. Danny’s Bed is an antique bed that seems to be tied to the mysterious seven year old boy ghost known as Danny. Danny is not a fan of others having his favorite piece of …
Tybee Island Police Blotter 6/10/24-6/23/24 Updates from Savannah's Beach
In this week’s bonus episode, we’re going back to the Tybee Island Police Blotter to talk about some of the crazy things that go on on the island right outside of Savannah, Georgia. It’s good to be back and discuss emitting odors again. We …
Scary Savannah is Back!
Howdy everyone! We wanted to drop a little announcement - starting this week, we’re back! We’ve enjoyed our little sabbatical to rejuvenate ourselves and now we’re ready to bring you the stories you’ve been waiting for, starting with anothe…
Tybee Island Police Blotter 5/13/24-6/09/24 Updates from Savannah's Beach
In this week’s bonus episode, we’re going back to the Tybee Island Police Blotter to talk about some of the crazy things that go on on the island right outside of Savannah, Georgia. There's more expired registrations than there are grains o…
Show Update and miscellaneous 5/26/24
This is an update regarding our show. We've been going since Halloween 2021 and haven't missed issuing an episode every Sunday since then. This has been a lot of fun and we love doing it, but we've come to the point where we need to step ba…
Tybee Island Police Blotter 4/30/24-5/12/24 Updates from Savannah's Beach
In this week’s bonus episode, we’re going back to the Tybee Island Police Blotter to talk about some of the crazy things that go on on the island right outside of Savannah, Georgia. Plenty of odors abound, plus we had a candlelight party at…
Mystery Sounds - Unexplained Sounds
This week we're releasing an episode from our Patreon vault. We're going to be talking about some haunting mystery sounds, including UVB-76, the Bloop, Julia, and Sky Quakes! Find us on the web: https://www.scarysavannahandbeyond.com Hate a…
Tybee Island Police Blotter 4/15/24-4/28/24 Updates From Savannah's Beach / Orange Crush
In this week’s bonus episode, we’re going back to the Tybee Island Police Blotter to talk about some of the crazy things that go on on the island right outside of Savannah, Georgia. This week we have a lot of ground to cover, and that invol…
The Fox Sisters and the Origins of the Spiritualism Movement
This week we delve into the origins of the spiritualism movement that swept across America in the mid 1800s, and discuss the roles of the Fox sisters, Maggie, Kate, and Leah. And yes, we found a way to bring Harry Houdini into this episode.…
Tybee Island Police Blotter 4/1/24-4/14/24 Updates from Savannah's Beach
In this week’s bonus episode, we’re going back to the Tybee Island Police Blotter to talk about some of the crazy things that go on on the island right outside of Savannah, Georgia. This week we seem to have a plethora of people claiming to…
The Phantom of Ridgeway
This week our computer died on us - so we had to get it fixed. Unfortunately that means we weren't able to record this week's episode - but so that we don't leave you without content, we're going to release one of our Patreon episodes! In t…
Tybee Island Police Blotter 3/18/24-3/31/24 Updates from Savannah's Beach
In this week’s bonus episode, we’re going back to the Tybee Island Police Blotter to talk about some of the crazy things that go on on the island right outside of Savannah, Georgia. This week, there's a rash of headlight violations, and eve…
Bigfoot: Is He Real? And Is He Vegan?
This week we set out to discover the origins and lore of Bigfoot, and include some eyewitness accounts of their experiences with the elusive (possibly vegan) creature. On What We’re Watching we talk about the 1972 classic “The Legend of Bog…
Tybee Island Police Blotter 3/4/24-3/17/24 Updates from Savannah's Beach
In this week’s bonus episode, we’re going back to the Tybee Island Police Blotter to talk about some of the crazy things that go on on the island right outside of Savannah, Georgia. This week, there’s a machete, women missing some clothing …
The 1979 Ghost Train Fire, Sydney, Australia
This week we dive into the mysterious unsolved fire at an amusement park on the Syndey Harbor, Luna Park. What caused the fire on the ride “The Ghost Train”, taking the lives of seven people. Was it arson? Or faulty wiring? Or a discarded c…
Tybee Island Police Blotter 2/19/24-3/3/24 Updates from Savannah's Beach
In this week’s bonus episode, we’re going back to the Tybee Island Police Blotter to talk about some of the crazy things that go on on the island right outside of Savannah, Georgia. This week, there’s contraband at the rest home, a disaster…
Spirits in the Ozarks, The Crescent Hotel, America’s Most Haunted Hotel
This week we explore the history of the spirits that haunt America’s most haunted hotel, the Crescent Hotel & Spa in Eureka Springs, Arkansas. On What We’re Watching we talk about the television show Ghosts: UK Version. On Layla and Coffee …
Tybee Island Police Blotter 2/5/24-2/18/24 Updates From Savannah's Beach
In this week’s bonus episode, we’re going back to the Tybee Island Police Blotter to talk about some of the crazy things that go on on the island right outside of Savannah, Georgia. This week, the odors continue to emit, and people love …
Ep. 86: Is Jimmy Hoffa on a Golf Course in Savannah?
This week we dive into the mysterious disappearance of Jimmy Hoffa, and its possible ties to Savannah. Find out if Crystal can make it as a 1950s housewife. On What We’re Watching we talk about the 2024 disaster of a game that’s supposed to…
Tybee Island Police Blotter 1/15/24-2/4/24 Updates from Savannah's Beach
In this week’s bonus episode, we’re going back to the Tybee Island Police Blotter to talk about some of the crazy things that go on on the island right outside of Savannah, Georgia. This week, someone checks out of their room and thinks the…
Winner announced for our "Mystery at Hunter's Lodge" Game!
We announce the winner of our board game giveaway contest! Thanks for everyone who entered and keep listening as we're going to be doing more giveaways. Find us on the web: https://www.scarysavannahandbeyond.com Hate ads? Looking for extra …
Leonarda Cianciulli the Soap Making Cannibal
This week we’re going really dark with a story from the early 20th century exploring Italy’s first female serial killer. Trigger Warning - Listener Discretion advised. On What We’re Watching we talk about the 2024 show “Death and Other Deta…
Tybee Island Police Blotter 1/1/24-1/14/24 Updates from Savannah's Beach
In this week’s bonus episode, we’re going back to the Tybee Island Police Blotter to talk about some of the crazy things that go on on the island right outside of Savannah, Georgia. This week it’s the mystery of the missing golf cart - and …