Episodes
80: Jasmine Pace
In this episode, we cover the tragic case of 22-year-old Jasmine “Jazzy” Pace of Chattanooga, Tennessee, who went missing over Thanksgiving 2022 and was later found brutally murdered—stabbed more than 60 times and hidden in a suitcase near …
79: Aunt Jenny Johnson
In this episode, we’re heading deep into the hills of Appalachia to uncover the chilling and unforgettable story of Aunt Jenny Johnson and her sons, the infamous Brooks Gang. What began as a brutal act of violence during the Civil War—when…
5: Patty Striker
Patty Striker was found shot dead inside the Striker Premium Winery, the winery she and her husband owned in Athens, Tennessee on April 10, 2000. In her 2014, her widower shot both of their children then himself. The children survived, he…
57: Marty Davis
Marty Davis was a 35 year old Episcopalian priest in Chattanooga, TN. He was the first openly gay priest in the area and the youngest ordained priest in Tennessee at the time of his ordination. On the morning of July 16, 1997, Marty was fo…
78: Cleveland Odometer Fraud
From the 1970s through the 1990s, Cleveland, Tennessee wasn’t just known for church steeples and Southern charm. It was also ground zero for one of the most widespread white-collar crimes in the country: odometer fraud. In this episode, we…
77: The Georgia Guidestones
Mysterious, massive, and deeply controversial, the Georgia Guidestones stood for over 40 years before being reduced to rubble in a shocking 2022 bombing. Who built them? What did their eerie commandments mean? And why were they so feared? …
76: The Santa Claus murders
In December 1997, the quiet town of Santa Claus, Georgia was shaken by a heartbreaking tragedy. 20-year-old Jerry Scott Heidler broke into the Daniels family home, taking the lives of four loved ones and kidnapping three children. This w…
75: The Battle of Athens
In the summer of 1946, Athens, Tennessee, became the site of the only successful armed rebellion in America since the Revolutionary War. Enter the villain of this story: Paul Cantrell. Backed by Tennessee’s powerful political machine, Cant…
74: W.A. Guinn
In the Appalachian town once known as McCays—now Copperhill, Tennessee—a powerful lawyer was gunned down in cold blood, setting off a whirlwind of scandal, betrayal, and courtroom drama. Was it a hired hit orchestrated by his wealthy wife, …
73: The Greenbriar Ghost
When Elva Zona Heaster Shue was found dead at the bottom of the stairs, her husband Edward “Trout” Shue insisted it was an accident. But Zona’s mother knew better, because Zona’s ghost told her the truth. This chilling case is the only kno…
72: Sheriff Burch Biggs
Burch Biggs was no ordinary sheriff. From moonshine raids as a teen to wielding political power in Polk County, TN, his name became synonymous with corruption, scandal, and backroom deals. He built a legacy through intimidation, rigged elec…
71: The Hedden Brothers
We’re heading back to Polk County, Tennessee, where moonshine, murder, and family feuds ran deep. After covering Bill Hedden’s case, we dug deeper and uncovered the wild, violent history of his uncle, Garrett Hedden. From shooting his own b…
70: The HL Hunley
In this episode, Randa dives into the story of the H.L. Hunley, the Confederate submarine that made history as the first to sink an enemy ship in combat. Disappearing shortly after its successful attack in 1864, the Hunley remained lost for…
69: Karen Liner
Our community has been shaken by the tragic news of a homicidevof Karen Liner on January 27, 2025 in Cleveland, Tennessee. Since then, her ex-husband, Craig Liner, has been charged in her death. This hits close to home for all of us, and ou…
68: Bratcher Family
On March 23, 1955, what started as a simple fishing trip in rural Tennessee ended in a brutal family slaying. Henry Bratcher and his cousin Billy Gibbs were enjoying the warmer weather when a disagreement (believed to be over money) turned …
67: Casket Girls
New Orleans is no stranger to dark and twisted history, but few stories are as eerie as the legend of the Casket Girls. Sent from France in the 1700s to be the colony’s future brides, these pale skinned women arrived with coffin like trunks…
Breaking Cleveland, TN News: Karen Liner
Our community has been shaken by the devastating homicide of Karen Liner, a well-known local realtor. On January 27th Karen was found at her home at 135 Arthur Lane NW, and investigators have are still actively working the scene. 61-year-o…
66: Sharon George
In the summer of 1982, a young woman’s life was brutally cut short in a case that would remain unsolved for years, only to reveal a twisted tale of jealousy, manipulation, and murder. This is the story of Sharon Elise George, a recent high …
65: Mothman
Episode 65 is here, and it’s a cryptid classic! This week we’re uncovering the mystery of the Mothman. Is he a warning, a menace, or just the world’s creepiest night owl? Tune in as we flutter through the lore, the sightings, and the sp…
64: Constable Bill Hedden
This episode explores the chilling 1942 deaths of Lecia Headen, Arlene Dillon Glowan, and her two-year-old son in Polk County, TN. The case centers on Constable Bill Hedden, Lecia’s brother-in-law, whose erratic behavior and conflicting te…
63: Patrice Endres
In this episode, we dive into the chilling case of Patrice Endres, a beloved hair salon owner who vanished without a trace on April 15, 2004, in Cumming, Georgia. Patrice disappeared in broad daylight during a 13-minute gap, leaving behind …
62: JT Lutz & the creation of the TBI
In 1949, J.T. Lutz was murdered at his home in Greene County, Tennessee, sparking significant public concern and frustration over the lack of progress in solving the case. This unsolved crime ultimately led to the creation of the Tennessee …
Bonus Episode: Cleveland, TN Spooky Thangs and Hauntings
HAPPY HALLOWEEN! We are excited to share some local haunts along with Randa’s personal ghosty experience for THE SPOOKIEST DAY OF THE YEAR! Tune in for some spooky Cleveland stories about The Phantom Monk of Charleston, Nina Craigmiles, …
61: Cleveland Unsolved
Instead of sharing spooky tales for Halloween, we’re bringing you something even scarier…. real life cases from Cleveland, Tennessee that remain unsolved to this day. In this episode, we’ll discuss the murder of Barbara Schow Mather, and t…
60: Smoky Mountains National Park Disappearances
Tune in as Randa delves into the mysterious disappearances in The Great Smoky Mountains National Park.
59: Spooky Woods
Hey guys! We are back for our most informal episode yet. This is mostly about what we have been up to the last month and some chit chat about spooky things in the woods. If banter isn't your thing, we will see you next episode! We can't wai…
58: Storyville
Storyville was a legally recognized red-light district in New Orleans, Louisiana, from 1897 to 1917. It was established to regulate vice activities within a specific area of the city. Storyville became famous not only for its legal good tim…
56: Lake Lanier
Join Ashley for this Spooky Thang on Lake Lanier. Lake Lanier, located in northern Georgia, has a reputation for being haunted, which stems from a combination of tragic events and urban legends. Since its creation in the 1950s, the lake has…
55: Georgia Tann
Our hair fact is more of a beauty fact this week, but it is about Rosemary and Catsor Oils! Join Ashley on this episode of another baby thief located right here in Tennessee. Beulah George "Georgia" Tann was a social worker and notorious …
54: Pappy Gate
Our long winded hair fact is about summertime blonde maintenance and realistic expectations for highlight services. Join Randa on this episode about the "Pappygate" heist. "Pappygate" is the term coined for a notorious bourbon theft tha…
53: The Devil's Tramping Grounds & The Wampus Cat
Follow Randa on this spooky woods Spooky Thang. The Devil's Tramping Ground is a mysterious site located in Chatham County, North Carolina. It is a circular patch of barren land about 40 feet in diameter where, according to local legend, n…
52: Tony and Susan Alamo
Remember those snazzy Jean jackets celebrities wore in the 90’s? Well let us tell you about how those were made…. Tony and Susan Alamo were the founders of the Alamo Christian Foundation, a controversial religious group. They gained notor…
51: Missing: Dennis Martin
The disappearance of Dennis Martin in 1969 is a mysterious case that occurred in the Great Smoky Mountains National Park. Dennis, a 6-year-old boy, vanished during a family camping trip. Despite extensive search efforts, he was never found.…
50: Cades Cove Spooky Thangs
Dive into the eerie mysteries of Cades Cove with Randa as she unveils spine-chilling tales of the disappearing cabin, the Cussin Cover, and the haunting lights that linger in the shadows.
49: Jennifer
This case involves a woman named Jennifer's death that the Bradley County Sheriff’s office ruled a suicide, with little to no investigation. Was she erratic and unraveling, or did her boyfriend shoot her on that March night? To check out …
48: Meriwether Lewis
Meriwether Lewis, of Lewis and Clark fame, died under mysterious circumstances in 1809. His death, officially ruled a suicide, has prompted speculation and conspiracy theories over the years. Some theories suggest foul play, citing incons…
47: Episode Updates
Randa has an update on some of our cases. - The Murdaughs from Episode 14 - Pauline Pusser, wife of Buford Pusser from Episodes 31, 32, & 33 - Bardstown from Episode 22 Also, have you ever heard of the Moon Eyed People?
46: Natalee Holloway
Natalee Ann Holloway was an 18 year old whose disappearance made international news after she vanished on May 30, 2005, in Aruba. Holloway lived in Mountain Brook, Alabama, and graduated from Mountain Brook High School shortly before the tr…
45: Eric Robert Rudolph
Join Randa for the story about Eric Rudolph and how he evaded capture for years. Eric Robert Rudolph is an American convicted serial bomber that carried out a series of bombings across the southern United States during the 1990s. The most …
44: The Killer Twins: Denice & Debbi Graham
Debbi and Denice were twins but couldn’t be more different. After the death of their mother the twins went their separate ways. Denice went on to meet the love of her life while working at Blockbuster in Cleveland, Tennessee. However, thei…