Episodes
Fixing Misreported Information: The Case of The Sodder Children
 A few weeks ago, we got an email from a relative of the Sodder children — and what she had to say stopped us in our tracks. For decades, certain details about this case have been misreported, repeated so often they’ve become part of the st…
The Case of Melanie Metheny
 The case we have for you today is about a devoted mother who had plans to return to school and build a better future for herself and her children. But on what seemed like an ordinary day of running errands, she vanished without a trace. Th…
The Case of Sister Roberta Elam
In the summer of 1977, Sister Roberta Elam was enjoying a peaceful afternoon on the grounds of her convent in West Virginia - until her life was tragically cut short. She was found murdered, a crime that shocked both the religious community…
Vanished Without a Trace: The Story of Brenda Gail Lambert Told by Her Sisters
In this emotional episode of Mountain State Mysteries, Mark Covey sits down with Christy and Pat, the sisters of Brenda Gail Lambert, who vanished under mysterious circumstances. Together, they recount Brenda’s life, her disappearance, and …
The Case of Brenda Gail Lambert
The case we have for you today is about a mother who disappeared on the night of her son's birthday party in 1992. This is the case of Brenda Gail Lambert. If you have any information regarding the disappearance of Brenda Gail Lambert, or …
The Case of Dr. Ebb "Doc" Whitley
The case we have for you today is one about a beloved small-town doctor who died in a mysterious house fire, suspicion quickly fell on his caretaker's son. He's arrested, convicted, and sent to prison. But years later, new evidence emerged …
The Case of The Beckley John Doe
In 1972, a young man was found dead along route 19 outside of Beckley, Wv. No ID. No Family. Just a pair of jungle boots and a story about heading south to join the military. Over 50 years later, he's still known only as John Doe. Who was h…
The Case of Blanche Dempsey (Mini Episode)
The case we have for you today is one we've heard whispers about for years, but never truly dug into-until now. We're furious because an innocent woman lost her life, and the story that follows is as heartbreaking as it is enringing. This i…
The Case of The Mad Butcher of West Virginia
The case we have for you today is as chilling as it is mysterious. Seven men vanished under separate circumstances - yet many believe they are all victims of the same brutal killer. Centered around the quiet town of Oak Hill, West Virginia,…
The Case of Randall Lee Smith (The Appalachian Trail Killer) - Virginia
The case we have for you today is the disturbing case of Randall Lee Smith, the infamous Appalachian Trail Killer. What Led him to murder two hikers? and why years later, did he return to the trail to kill again? Did it have something to do…
The Legend of The Grafton Monster
This week Courtney takes you to the spring of 1964, a reporter in Grafton, West Virginia claimed to have seen a massive, headless creature lurking near the river. Soon, Sightings of the Grafton Monster spread like wildfire, drawing monster …
Behind The Mic: AMA with Mark & Courtney
In this special AMA episode, Mark and Courtney pull back the curtain and answer your burning questions-from behind-the-scenes secrets and favorite cases to chilling listeners theories and what keeps them up at night. Nothing's off-limits, s…
REVISIT: The Case of Sargent James Lee Haynes
on December 7th, 1963, James Lee Haynes went missing after hitchhiking. some say he was a victim of the bad butcher others say he was killed by three men after a barroom fight. This is the true and updated story of James Lee Haynes. Sourc…
The Case of Aliayah Lunsford
The case we have for you today is about a three-year-old girl that seemingly vanishes from rural West Virginia in 2011, answers don't come quickly. But as the years pass, a witness comes forward with information that changes everything  …
The Case of Sid Hatfield
In this episode of Mountain State Mysteries, we dive into the life and legacy of Sid Hatfield, the fearless police chief who became a symbol of resistance during the bloody labor wars of West Virginia. Nest known for his role in the 1920 Ma…
The Case of The WVU CO-EDS Mared Malarik and Karen Farrell PT.2
The case we have for you today is about two WVU freshmen, Mared Malarik and Karen Farrell, who vanished while hitchhiking in Morgantown on a cold night in 1970. Months later, their decapitated remains were found in a remote wooded area, Spa…
The Case of The WVU CO-EDS MARED MALARIK and KAREN FARRELL PT.1
The case we have for you today is about two WVU freshmen, Mared Malarik and Karen Farrell, who vanished while hitchhiking in Morgantown on a cold night in 1970. Months later, their decapitated remains were found in a remote wooded area, Spa…
The Case of Brenda Gail Lambert
The case we have for you today is about a mother who disappeared on the night of her son's birthday party in 1992. This is the case of Brenda Gail Lambert. If you have any information regarding the disappearance of Brenda Gail Lambert, or …
The Case of Mamie Thurman
Today's case is one of the most enduring mysteries in West Virginia's history, involving murder, scandal, and conspiracy. This case of Mamie Thurman. SOURCES - Mamie Thurman - Wikipedia The murder of Mamie Thurman remains a mystery - Loga…
The Case of Samantha Burns
In November 2002, 19-year-old Samantha Burns disappeared after talking to her mom on the phone. The next morning her car was discovered engulfed in flames in a remote area. Her case became one of the states most haunting mysteries. This is …
The Case of Cynthia Jane Miller
The case I have for you today is one that happened in theoretically in my backyard. A case that has always made me wonder who could killer a teacher the day before her wedding? This is the case of Cynthia Jane Miller. SOURCES - COLD CASE …
The Case of Cheryl Edwards and Charlita Singleton (Virginia)
The case we have for you today is about two co-workers who were found stabbed to death at a mall in Virginia in November of 1996. This is the case of Charyl Edwards and Charlita Singleton. SOURCES - 23 years later, family still looking for…
Urban Legend: Screaming Jenny
The legend of Screaming Jenny haunts the tracks of Harpers Ferry, West Virginia. With many variations of her story, this tale captivates all who hears it. Join Mark on his journey through these urban legends. MOUNTAIN STATE MYSTERIES LINK…
The Case of David, Janette Henderson, and Martha Barber (The Murders At The Maybeury Mansion)
The case I have for you today happened on a day that was supposed to be full of love. Instead, it ended with three people being murdered in a mansion on a hill. This is the case of David, Janette Henderson, and Martha Barber. Better known a…
The Case of Cheryl Flippo (The Cabin 13 Murder)
The case I have for you today is about a husband and wife that went to Babcock State Park to enjoy a romantic getaway. That is until intruders broke into the cabin and killed his wife... Or is that really what happened? SOURCES - Cheryl Fl…
The Case of James "Whitey" Bulger
The case we have for you today is about a man whose name became synonymous with organized crime in Boston. This is the case of James "whitey" bulger. SOURCES - Whitey Bulger killing was 'planned' and took just 7 minutes, Justice Department…
The Flatwoods Monster
In 1953, a small group of residents in Flatwoods, West Virginia set out into the night in search of a crashed UFO. What they encountered instead was a bizarre aircraft, seemingly operated by a monster. This is the story of the Flatwoods Mon…
ANNOUNCEMENT: APPALACHIAN GHOST TOURS
We're excited to announce that we've launched a ghost tour company in collaboration with our friends from Three Sisters Paranormal! We can't wait for you to join Appalachian Ghost Tours on one of our many spine-chilling adventures. Info For…
The Case of The Wetzel County Jane Doe
The case I have for you today involves an unidentified woman whose identity remains a mystery to this day. This is the case of Wetzel County Jane Doe. SOURCES - Wetzel County Jane Doe | Unidentified Wiki | Fandom 56UFWV (doenetwork.org) WV…
The Case of Theresa Ann Woods
Our case this week is Theresa Ann Woods. When 13-year-old Theresa Ann Woods left school and waited for her friend at the local 7-Eleven, she went missing. Later, her remains were found by a creek nine miles away from where she was last seen…
Missing In the Mountains
In the state of West Virginia, there are 142 open missing person cases. We believe that is 142 too many. These are just some of the missing people from the state of West Virginia If you have any information on any of these cases, please us…
The Case of Serial Killer Eugene Blake (West Virginia & Ohio)
The case we have for you today involves the period between 1982 and 1984, focusing on Eugene Blake, a serial killer who perpetrated murders in West Virginia and Ohio. SOURCES - Eugene Blake Denied Parole, Next Hearing In 10 Years | News, S…
UFO'S Over West Virginia (Mini Episode)
Today, Courtney is excited to share an intriguing UFO article she recently stumbled upon. This article has really piqued our curiosity, prompting us to take a closer look at the night skies over West Virginia. The article details some fasci…
The Case of Michelle "Shelly" Goots - Michaels PT.2
Today, we dive into the case of Michelle "Shelly" Michaels—a nurse and former West Virginia University cheerleader convicted of murdering her husband and committing arson. This is part one of her story. MOUNTAIN STATE MYSTERIES LINKS - WEB…
The Case of Michelle "Shelly" Goots - Michaels PT.1
Today, we dive into the case of Michelle "Shelly" Michaels—a nurse and former West Virginia University cheerleader convicted of murdering her husband and committing arson. This is part one of her story. MOUNTAIN STATE MYSTERIES LINKS - WEB…
The Case of Burley Kelley
The case we have for you today is long overdue for answers. We firmly believe the key answers are right in plain sight. Even after seven years, the family continues to seek closure. This is the case of Burley Kelley. MOUNTAIN STATE MYSTERI…
The Legend and Haunting of John Henry
The story I have for you today is one that everyone may know but you may not know the haunting behind it. This is the story of John henry and the haunting of the Big Bend Tunnel. MOUNTAIN STATE MYSTERIES LINKS - WEBSITE - Home | Mountains…
The Case of Jerry Ball
The case I have for you today is about a 16-year-old who got mad at his parents and ended up killing his entire family. this is the case of Jerry Ball. MOUNTAIN STATE MYSTERIES LINKS - WEBSITE - Home | Mountainstatemysteri (mountainstatemy…
The Case of Juliet Staunton Clark
The case we have for you today is about a woman whose life tried to bring her down so many times, but she always came out on top. That is until one night in August of 1953. This is the case of Juliet Staunton Clark. SOURCES - Juliet Lyell “…
The Case of Betty Blevins
The case we have for you today is about a woman whose life was suddenly taken, and her body was disposed of in one of the most tragic ways. This is the case of Betty Blevins. Website - Home | Mountainstatemysteri (mountainstatemysteriespod…