Grimly
Join Missy and Meg as we tell you some of the most creepy, grim and down right scariest stories the world (and the internet) has to offer, with a little bit of humor.
Episodes
Episode 72 - Reefer Cheese Ship: The El Fausto
In 1968 in the Canary Islands, a fishing vessel called the El Fausto left a port bound for Tazacorte on La Palma. The ship would never make it's destination but what happened before it was lost forever is just as bewildering and confusing a…
Episode 71 - Aloof but Interested: The Mysterious Death Of George Reeves
Before the superhero craze of the last few decades and even before Christopher Reeves would don the iconic "S" suit. There was George Reeves, a man who had a complicated relationship with his identity as the man of steel. His name would be …
Episode 70 - Speculation Panties: The lead masks of Vintém Hill
This podcast episode is brought to you by Pepsi (not really but wouldn’t that be cool!) In the 1960’s in an area outside of Rio. Two men ascended a hill, they wore matching raincoats, had notebook with cryptic instructions, eye protection m…
Episode 69-Blame Mercury: Tammy Lynn Leppert Disappearance
She was a beauty queen, model and was breaking into acting. Until she saw something that shouldn’t have seen and it caused everything to come crashing down. Soon after Tammy Lynn Leppert disappeared and she’s been missing since. This week w…
Episode 68- Naked in Solidarity: 10 cent beer night
Do you love baseball? How about beer? Or maybe a hot dog, or do you just love to be naked in public? Boy do I have a story for you. This week Meg and Missy are talking about an infamous baseball game, but this isn’t a typical baseball game.…
Episode 67- Two Martini Lunch: Harvey Milk
Harvey Milk was one of the first openly gay elected officials in US History. And while he had tons of support from his constituents and community, there were others that believed he should stay out of politics and stay in the closet. But Ha…
Episode 66- Basic White Fish: Craig Williamson Disappearance
In the early 90’s Craig Williamson went on a business trip to try to support his fish farm that he ran with his wife Christine, but he didn’t come home and seemingly vanished. Next there were confusing clues and sightings that had investiga…
Episode 65- Summer Bummer: The kidnapping of Melissa Brannen
During the holiday season in 1989, 5 year old Melissa Brannen went missing at a party. It was as if she vanished into thin air. The small Virginia community searched for weeks and a suspect was named and put on trial. But there is still so …
Episode 64- Spiritual Train: Annabelle
Locked away behind glass in the Warrens' Occult Museum, Annabelle looks like an ordinary Raggedy Ann doll, but her story is anything but innocent. Listen as we dive into the real-life case that helped inspire the Conjuring universe, a terri…
Episode 63- Strongest Thighs: The Disappearance of Bryce Laspisa
In 2013 a college student by the name of Bryce Laspisa had been acting strangely for a few weeks. His friends and girlfriend were so worried about him they were contacting his parents telling them that something was wrong. Bryce then makes …
Episode 62- USPS Beef: Georgia Rudolph
For decades Georgia Rudolph had been having vivid memories and dreams. The dreams and memories were of a place and time she had never been to, but they also seemed so familiar to her. This was the start of an incredible journey that some be…
Episode 61- Boopin' Snoots: Grizzly Man
Grizzly bears are beautiful, powerful, and dangerous. In the 90's and early 2000's there was man in Katmai National Park who took it upon himself to protect them and educate the general public about the grizzly. His methods were unorthodox …
Episode 60- Love to Forget: The Mary Celeste
In the 1870's a ship with an infamous reputation was given a new name and new ownership. This maiden voyage was supposed to be a new chapter for the ship and her crew. But then in early December, another ship find her adrift without her cre…
Episode 59- Raw Doggin’ : The Death of Patricia Bottarini
In May of 1997 Patricia (Patty) Bottarini went on a hike with her husband in Zion National Park. Then the unthinkable happened, she falls down the steep cliffs of the observation point trail to her death. Some people think it’s a tragic acc…
Episode 58- Full Sugar Soda: Kenny Veach and the M cave.
Put on your sunscreen kids, because we are heading to the desert. While watching a youtube video one day Kenny Veach left a comment that would put his life on a course that ultimately lead to his demise, or did it? This story has taken on a…
Episode 57- Shot in 1K: Gareth Williams Part 2
Are you still mad at us from last week? Let us make it up to you. This week we are diving into the investigation, coroners inquest and theories of what people think happened to Gareth Williams. Be sure to rate and review and as always, stay…
Episode 56-Kicking a can: The mysterious death of Gareth Williams Part 1
Hello everyone and a special hello to those fine people who make dot’s pretzels. Keep up the good work. This week we are going to the UK to dive into some real spy shit. Gareth Williams was a brilliant mathematician working in international…
Episode 55- OOF-ologist: The Men in Black
Sorry for the delay. I had to evade some weird, pasty guys in black suits for the last 24 hours. This week we are putting our kooky caps on and diving into the bizarre theories of men who have been around since the 1940’s. Are they here to …
Episode 54- Cute Menty B: The Bumblebee Road Murders
Buckle up guys because this episode is a big sad this week. Lisa Gurrieri and Brandon Rumbaugh were a sweet, young couple who decided to take an overnight camping trip for their anniversary. But instead of coming home they were killed in th…
Episode 53- Flip The Script: The 1881 Washer Woman Strike
Put on your boot cut jeans and get ready for a history lesson. This week we are going back in time to 1881 in Atlanta Georgia where Missy tells us a story about a group of badass women. These women were able to demand a better wages and res…
Episode 52- Nasty Jellybeans: The Kentucky Meat Shower
Alright guys, this episode is a weird one. But first we have to talk (and also complain) about sad movies. We then dive into one of the craziest true stories we have covered on this podcast. It’s a story about a farmer in Kentucky witnessin…
Episode 51- A Complete Mess: Betty and Barney Hill Part 2
Is what we were for this recording, because the horrors persist but so does our work email. This week we are wrapping up our Betty and Barney Hill story. We cover the hypnosis sessions and how the story became so famous. Be sure to rate and…
Episode 50- Mysterious Woman: The Betty and Barney Hill abduction (Part 1)
Welcome back! This week for our 50th episode we are diving into THE abduction story that changed the UFO scene forever. The Betty and Barney Hill abduction part 1. We will dig into the backstory of the couple, the night of the abduction and…
Episode 49: Little Treats- The Disappearance of Tim Molnar
Thank god January is over. But the horrors continue to persist, so go buy yourself a little treat to stay sane. This week the girls dive into the very weird disappearance of 19 year old Tim Molnar. A boy who seemingly decided to pick up and…
Episode 48: Fat Little Taco- El Chupacabra
Cue the sad trombone and get ready for another episode of Grimly. This week we are diving into another classic cryptid, the one and only goat sucker, El Chupacabra. Missy tells us the origins of the creature and how mainstream media and fol…
Episode 47- Art Money: The Merchant's House
On behalf of Meg and Missy, we apologize to all Gertrude's for the name slander. This week we dive in a New York house that has been around for almost 200 years and has some very active ghosts that dwell inside of it. The Merchant's house i…
Episode 46- A Better Robert: The mysterious death of Robert Johnson
Sorry for the delay, I'm going to go ahead and blame the ghost siri we caught during this episode recording for that. This week we once again talk pets and Meg's deep, deep hatred for January birthdays. We then dive into the life and myster…
Episode 45-Hot Mic: Robert Durst Part 2
Hello there! Welcome back to Grimly where we always have time to talk about our pets. This week we are wrapping up the infamous crimes of Robert Durst and how his participation in the documentary The Jinx unraveled everything. This includes…
Episode 44- Wet 24/7: Robert Durst part 1
Here we are 2025 and we are changing things up a bit. Since this is the week of Grimly’s one year anniversary, we decided to talk about a true crime case that is absolutely bonkers and shocked the world. And there is no one better or more w…
Episode 43- Full of Wine, full of cheese: Krampus
You better watch out, because it’s coming for you. Just kidding! It’s just your friendly podcast hosts. This week we are covering the Christmas Devil herself for the holiday season aka Krampus. We will dive into the origins, traditions and …
Episode 42- A Good Sniff: The Disappearance of The Sodder Children
Happy Honda Days and Merry Toyota-thon. We are back with a new episode. This week we talk about a huge unsolved mystery case that has haunted us for 80 years. On Christmas Eve in 1945 nine people went to bed in the Sodder family home. But t…
Episode 41-Butterfly face: The Ghost Blimp
Welcome back to Missy’s made up holiday. The girls have officially been recording for a year so happy recordaversary! This week we give you movie recommendations, talk about bomb cyclones and the labyrinth that is Meg’s mind. We also dive i…
Episode 40- It's a Wig: Anthony Pignataro
Welcome Back! This week the girls are talking about the worst/best pets, the 4B movement and like always, geography for some reason. We also dig into a classic forensic files case that covers a doctor who commits a few very heinous crimes t…
Episode 39- Worst Episode Yet: Kate Warne and the Baltimore Plot
"Worst Episode Yet" is a direct quote from Meg. This week give us a little grace. Missy is PISSED post the US presidential election and Meg has gone stir crazy from being cooped up after her ankle surgery. So we both lose it a bit during th…
Episode 38- Gird your loins: The mysterious disappearance of Eric Lewis
Hello friends, welcome back to Grimly. This week we are talking about a place close by to our home. Mount Rainier. We dive into the climbing world and a very bizarre disappearance of a man in 2010, Eric Lewis. Be sure to rate and review and…
Episode 37- Spooky & Kooky Road Trip: Waverly Hills Sanitorium
Happy Monday! I know we are all a bit of stressed with election week and it now becoming dark after lunch, but hopefully Missy and Meg can help. This week we are going to Louisville Kentucky to talk about what has been deemed, "The Most Hau…
Episode 36- Rama Bahama: The mysterious death of Christopher Case
Welcome back and Happy Halloween week! Today we are talking about a story that sounds like the premise of a scary movie, but is actually something that happened in real life. The mysterious death of Christopher Case has us wondering, do you…
Episode 35-Spooky Mittens: Daniel Laplante
Buckle up kids, because this episode has twists and turns like a rollercoaster. This week we are discussing the importance of locking your fucking doors! We start with a case that has one family being terrified by an entity in their walls, …
Episode 34- Weidos & Sluts Unite: Cursed Films
Welcome to the first October episode! This week we are talking all things spooky season, ya know, costumes, movies and curses. This week we are discussing what the idea of a "cursed film" can really mean and we look into 3 different movies …
Episode 33- Space Elevator: The Frederick Valentich Abduction
What's up my fellow space ants. Welcome back to a new episode of Grimly. This week we are digging into another mystery in the sky. The mysterious disappearance (a perhaps abduction) of Australian pilot Frederick Valentich Be sure to rate a…