The Murder Diaries
The Murder Diaries is a victim-focused true crime podcast. Hosts Natalie and Paige use straightforward storytelling to spotlight cold cases, missing persons, and suspicious deaths— often incorporating original audio from the victim’s friends and family. The podcast also includes monthly interviews about the true crime genre as a whole, whether that’s discussions on ethics, survivors sharing their stories, or other relevant topics. Connect with us at themurderdiariespodcast.com or on socials @themurderdiariespod
Episodes
Interview with Investigative Journalist Stephanie Tinsley
We're diving into a story that's currently unfolding in real time. But this time we have a special guest to join us to do that. This case is out of Memphis and is raising serious questions about the criminal justice system, eyewitness relia…
UNSCRIPTED: Laguna Beach
Paige brings Natalie up to speed on all the Laguna Beach drama, from iconic love triangles to the moments that defined early 2000s reality TV. Our Unscripted segment will be moving to its own RSS feed starting January 2026. Until then, you…
MISSING: Ali Lowitzer
In April of 2010, high school student Ali Lowitzer disappeared after getting off her school bus in her hometown of Spring, Texas. Her parents wonder if she was abducted and forced into the world of human trafficking, but the case has gone c…
UNSCRIPTED: The Kardashians ft. Gay Man with a Spray Tan
Video Version: https://youtu.be/psAwMWo_4jA Natalie & Paige are joined by the one and only Gay Man with a Spray Tan for a deep dive into all things Kardashian-- with a K! From reality TV to business empires, and everything in between, we'r…
Justice for Katie Palmer, a Conversation with John Palmer
As you listen to our interview with Katie Palmer’s husband, we want to share an important update. A Grayson County Grand Jury has indicted the driver, Cory Todd Foster, on a manslaughter charge in connection with Katie’s death in 2020. The …
UNSCRIPTED: Hilary Duff
Natalie & Paige deep dive into the life and career of Hilary Duff, from her Lizzie McGuire days to her pop music era and current TV success. They cover it all, including her early 2000s feud with Lindsay Lohan and some of her more problemat…
MISSING: Trevor Deely
On a cold, stormy night in Dublin, Trevor Deely left his office after a Christmas party and disappeared without a trace. Caught on CCTV one moment and gone the next, his case remains one of Ireland’s most haunting unsolved mysteries. If yo…
UNSCRIPTED: The Cult of American Apparel Documentary
This week on Unscripted, Natalie and Paige dive into the Cult of American Apparel documentary, dissecting the rise and fall of the iconic brand and the controversy surrounding its founder. From provocative marketing to toxic workplace cultu…
MURDERED: Sarah Boehm
Just 14 years old. A shy girl. A cheerleader. A member of the school band. One warm summer night, she told her older brother she was walking to a friend’s house for a sleepover. She never showed up. A few months later, hunters found her bo…
UNSCRIPTED: Ashlee Simpson
This week, Natalie and Paige spotlight Ashlee Simpson. You know, the younger Simpson sister who stepped out of Jessica’s shadow with a side part, a punk attitude, and a reality show of her own. From her chart-topping debut to that infamous …
Amanda Knox: Falsely accused and exonerated... TWICE.
You read that right, AMANDA FREAKING KNOX. From 2007 to 2015, Amanda spent nearly four years in an Italian prison, and eight years on trial for a crime she didn't commit. Her name became a global headline, but she's so much more than the st…
UNSCRIPTED: Jessica Simpson
Natalie and Paige are throwing it back to the early 2000s to revisit the rise of Jessica Simpson, the Southern sweetheart who went from MTV reality TV gold to billion-dollar brand mogul. They unpack the pop culture storm that was Newlyweds,…
Introducing: Crime House Daily
Crime doesn’t take a day off. And neither does Crime House Daily. Hosted by self-defense instructor and advocate for victims, Katie Ring, Crime House Daily is coming to you twice every weekday, covering the biggest crime stories as they unf…
MISSING: Denise Pflum
In 1986, Denise Pflum was about to graduate from high school and begin the rest of her promising, young life. But one afternoon she left home and was never seen or heard from again. Denise Pflum is a Caucasian female with brown hair and br…
UNSCRIPTED: Unknown Number Documentary
When a Michigan teenager became the target of relentless cyberbullying, no one expected the perpetrator to be her own mother. Netflix’s Unknown Number tells the shocking true story of Kendra Licari, a woman who catfished her daughter for ov…
MURDERED: Elizabeth Salgado
When 26-year-old Elizabeth Salgado moved from her home in Mexico to Provo, Utah to learn English and join the large community of Mormons, she was excited for a new adventure. Less than three weeks after she arrived, Elizabeth vanished from …
UNSCRIPTED: Britney Spears
From the Mickey Mouse Club to global superstardom, public unraveling, and a controversial conservatorship, Britney Spears’ life has been anything but ordinary. This week on Unscripted, Natalie and Paige trace the highs, the heartbreaks, and…
SUSPICIOUS DEATH: Andra "Andee" Adams
After a deadly altercation in Seattle, Andra "Andee" Adams was run over and killed by her boyfriend's Chrysler 300. Now, her loved ones are demanding answers and accountability for the circumstances surrounding her suspicious and heartbreak…
UNSCRIPTED: Paris Hilton
Join Natalie and Paige as they dive deep into the glitz, glam, and grit of the original influencer: Paris Hilton. From iconic reality TV moments to building a billion-dollar empire, the girls unpack Paris’ rise to fame, her reinvention, and…
Seeking Justice for Molly Bish, a Conversation with Heather Bish
Original Air Date: 11/2/23 Today on The Murder Diaries we’re speaking with Heather Bish, whose little sister, Molly, was murdered 25 years ago. Her case remains unsolved to this day. In our conversation, Heather tells us all about who Moll…
UNSCRIPTED: Lindsay Lohan
This week on Unscripted, Natalie and Paige dive into the rollercoaster life of early 2000s icon Lindsay Lohan. From teen stardom and tabloid chaos to her quiet married life and recent revival in Hollywood, the ladies unpack the highs, the l…
MURDERED: Stacey Colbert
Stacey Colbert had just graduated college and was beginning to build her own life when she vanished from her apartment in Columbus, Ohio, seemingly without a trace. Six years later, in 2004, Stacey’s remains were found 40 minutes away from …
UNSCRIPTED: Bikini Pics, Crypto Bros, and Cruise Ship Chaos
This week on Unscripted, Natalie and Paige dive into two recent news stories exposing the persistent grip of toxic masculinity, starting with a deli worker shamed for posting a bikini pic on her day off, and moving to the outrageous inciden…
MISSING: Lonene "Lonnie" Rogers
Every year, between one in every 1,000 to 2,000 babies is born deaf or hard of hearing. For about 90% of these children, they’re born into hearing families, families who suddenly begin a journey they never expected. Maxine and Raymond Raffl…
UNSCRIPTED: Big News & a Bit of Nostalgia
This week on Unscripted, Natalie and Paige have an announcement you won’t want to miss. Seriously, tune in for the big reveal! The duo also takes a quick dive into the latest headlines surrounding the Duggar and Bates families and reflect o…
MISSING: Dia Abrams
Lydia “Dia” Abrams was a wealthy and glamorous 65-year-old widow living on a beautiful 117-acre ranch in the idyllic mountain town of Idyllwild, California. From the outside looking in, she seemed to have it all. But on June 6, 2020, after …
UNSCRIPTED: Oceangate Submersible Disaster
This week on Unscripted, Natalie and Paige plunge into the depths of Netflix’s gripping new documentary Titan: The Oceangate Disaster. The doc explores the ill-fated 2023 submersible expedition to the Titanic wreck site that captured global…
Investigative Podcaster & Host of Ice Cold Case: Madison McGhee
Today on the Murder Diaries, we are honored to sit down with our friend Madison McGhee. She's the creator and the voice behind "Ice Cold Case," a deeply personal and powerful investigative podcast about her father's unsolved murder. Like ma…
UNSCRIPTED: The Olsen Twins
This week on Unscripted, Natalie and Paige peel back the layers on Mary-Kate and Ashley Olsen, the famously private twins who went from child stars on Full House to the understated queens of high fashion. From oversized sunglasses to oversi…
MISSING: Rachel Good
After a young mother vanishes, her family uncovers a shocking and scandalous secret that could explain what happened to her. If you have any information about the disappearance of Rachel Nicole Good, tips can be submitted anonymously to Sp…
UNSCRIPTED: Hypnotherapy, Healing & Past Lives with Mallorie Shannon
This week on Unscripted, Natalie and Paige sit down with Mallorie Shannon, a certified Life Coach, Reiki Master, and Consulting Hypnotist with a background in psychology, to explore the intersection of traditional therapy and metaphysical h…
MISSING: Emma Fillipoff
Original Air Date: 8/17/22 On the evening of November 28, 2012, 26-year-old Emma Fillipoff caught an acquaintance’s attention as she stood barefoot, hugging shoes to her chest on a street corner. Uneasy, almost nervous about crossing. She …
UNSCRIPTED: Forever Young? Bryan Johnson’s Billion-Dollar Biohacking Experiment
In this week’s episode of Unscripted, Natalie and Paige go deep on Don’t Die: The Man Who Wants to Live Forever, the new Netflix documentary from the executive producer of Tiger King. The film follows tech entrepreneur-turned-biohacker Brya…
MURDERED: Kimberly Sue Morse
Kimberly Sue Morse was just 32 years old and a month away from graduating cosmetology school when she was attacked and brutally murdered in her Rhode Island apartment. To this day, there has been no motive identified, no solid leads, and no…
UNSCRIPTED: Who's the Real Villain Here? AITA Edition
This week on Unscripted, Natalie and Paige dive into the drama of the internet’s favorite moral battleground: AITA (Am I the Asshole?). They read anonymous submissions and Reddit classics, offering their unfiltered takes on who's in the wro…
MURDERED: Michael Tardio & Christopher Monson
A sale of stolen jewellery goes very wrong resulting in the murders of two men which remain unsolved to this day. If you have any information regarding the murders of Michael Tardio and Christopher Monson, please contact the Los Angeles P…
UNSCRIPTED: Cole Young’s MLB Dream Debut, Arnold Schwarzenegger’s Family Drama, Sydney Sweeney Soap Scandal & the HomeGoods Conspiracy
This week on Unscripted, Natalie and Paige are back with another whirlwind of headlines and hot takes. They celebrate Cole Young’s dream debut with the Mariners: three days of baseball magic capped off with a walk-off RBI. Then things get p…
Stalking Awareness Advocate: Jake Deptula
Today, we're joined by a very special guest, Jake Deptula, our friend and advocate. Jake has become a trusted voice for stalking survivors through his work on "Strictly Stalking" a podcast dedicated to raising awareness about the hidden dan…
UNSCRIPTED: Taylor Swift Takes Back Her Masters
This week on Unscripted, Natalie & Paige dive deep into the exciting news: Taylor Swift has officially bought back her masters. After years of public battles, re-recordings, and reclaiming her voice, Taylor has finally turned the tables. L…
MURDERED: Molly Dattilo
Young, beautiful, and smart, she was a 23-year-old college student and scholarship runner at Eastern Kentucky University. She was about to start her fifth and final year and was very close to graduating. She was spending the summer living w…