Episodes
Her Husbands Keep Dying - #206
Betty Neumar was married five different times over the course of her life. And each of those 5 men ended up dead, under mysterious circumstances. This episodes dives in to the details of these deaths, and the investigation in to what many c…
Magic Keeps Screaming - NMR #92
Magic has been screaming a lot lately, but don't be alarmed, he is not being harmed! Daryn is surrounded by feet at all times. Head over the ShakenAndDisturbed.com for new merchandise, blogs for our episodes, YouTube videos, and Patreon! …
"Devil in the Desert" with ABC News' Matt Gutman - #205
We got to sit down with ABC News chief national correspondent Matt Gutman, who is the host of the ABC News true crime podcast "Devil In The Desert." Matt talks about what drew him to cover this case after following it for over a decade as w…
Socks In An Airplane Bathroom? - NMR #91
This week we're chatting about whether straight people should join queer sports leagues, and Daryn wonders why people where socks-only into airplane bathrooms! To get this episode ONE WEEK EARLY sign up as a Sussy Radish on Patreon! Watch…
Horror In Ocean City, Maryland - #204
In 2002, the murders of Joshua Ford and Martha Crutchley shocked the beach town of Ocean City, Maryland. Erika and Benjamin Sifrit quickly became the focus of an intense investigation that revealed a dark and unexpected truth. What began as…
Who's Your Zaddy Now? - NMR #90
John and Daryn discuss the etymology of "Daddy." Daryn talks about the very sweet reunion she had with Snoopy after 8 days away in New York City! To get this episode ONE WEEK EARLY sign up as a Sussy Radish on Patreon! Watch and listen to…
The Goleta Postal Shootings - #203
Goleta, California is the epicenter of a shocking act of workplace violence at a local mail facility. As investigators piece together what happened, a disturbing pattern begins to emerge with a woman named Jennifer San Marco. To get this e…
A Cherry Obituary - NMR #89
Daryn gets her Kates mixed up and John wants you to try Cherry Obituary! To get this episode ONE WEEK EARLY sign up as a Sussy Radish on Patreon! Watch and listen to this and every other episode several days early on Patreon! Patreon memb…
Horror In Knoxville (Flashback to #170)
Taking this week as a break but will be back with all new episodes next week! In the winter of 2007, Channon Christian and Christopher Newsom Jr. fell victim to a horrific carjacking incident that spiraled into one of the largest scandals …
Prepare For Torture, John - NMR #88
John got a personal trainer and it's going both well and not well at the same time. Daryn will be in a couple of cities where you can meet her this summer! To get this episode ONE WEEK EARLY sign up as a Sussy Radish on Patreon! Watch and…
The Chicago Rippers - #202
This week we cover the terrifying case of The Chicago Rippers, a sadistic cult-like group responsible for a string of brutal murders in the 1980s. Led by Robin Gecht, the group included Edward Spreitzer, and brothers Andrew and Thomas Kokor…
Karen Read + John's Tony Awards Weekend - NMR #87
We discuss the Karen Read trial (BEFORE the verdict!) and John recaps his incredible Tony Awards weekend. Daryn met a TV legend! To get this episode ONE WEEK EARLY sign up as a Sussy Radish on Patreon! Watch and listen to this and every o…
"Sherri Papini: Caught In a Lie" Documentary Reaction - #201
Sherri Papini was kidnapped and went missing for 22 days. Or did she? She lied to the FBI, but is she truly a liar? We break down the complicated Max documentary "Sherri Papini: Caught In A Lie" on this week's episode. To get this episode …
John and David Archuleta Made Contact - NMR #86
It has happened. John and David...a match made in heaven. Hear the whole story about John's Pride weekend in this week's episode! To get this episode ONE WEEK EARLY sign up as a Sussy Radish on Patreon! Watch and listen to this and every …
The Killer Cadets - #200
Families and friends are shocked to find out that two standout students with a military career ahead of them were the ones behind a gruesome and disturbing murder. To get this episode ONE WEEK EARLY sign up as a Sussy Radish on Patreon! W…
La Boo Boos + Menendez Update - NMR #85
Daryn has introduced John to a new thing he is going to become absolute obsessed with. We update everyone on the latest details in the Menendez Brothers. To get this episode ONE WEEK EARLY sign up as a Sussy Radish on Patreon! Watch and l…
The Long Island Serial Killer - #199
In this episode, we dive into the chilling mystery of the Gilgo Beach murders, a case that haunted Long Island for over a decade. With new developments and a suspect named Rex Heuermann now in custody, the investigation has taken a dramatic…
Cotton Candy and Cowboy Carp - NMR #84
Daryn gives her review of both Cowboy Carter and Cotton Candy KitKats. John wants Daryn to see the new Marvel movie (what else is new!). Starting this week we are releasing NMR and our weekly cases in alternate weeks! Sign up for Patreon t…
Las Vegas Firefighter Destroys His Family - #198
Shauna Tiaffay, a beloved Las Vegas cocktail waitress and mother, was brutally murdered in 2012. Investigators were shocked to find out who the person was who hired a killer to carry out the fatal attack. This true crime story exposes a dev…
The Black Dahlia Murder - #197
This week we cover the infamous Black Dahlia case, exploring the brutal 1947 murder of Elizabeth Short and the chilling theories that still surround her death. We examine the evidence, media frenzy, and prime suspect George Hodel, whose own…
Darynchella & John needs to be confident - NMR #83
Daryn reports back about seeing Lady Gaga and Missy Elliot at Coachella. John's boyfriend works at the Santa Monica Pier! SUBSCRIBE TO SHAKEN AND DISTURBED ON YOUTUBE! Watch and listen to this and every other episode several days early on…
The Idaho Student Murders: What We Know Now - #196
In this episode, we break down the chilling details of the Idaho Student Murders that shook the nation in 2022. We revisit the tragic case involving the brutal killings of University of Idaho students Kaylee Goncalves, Madison Mogen, Xana K…
"A Body In The Snow: The Trial of Karen Read" Documentary Reaction - #195
In this episode, we dive into the controversial case of Karen Read, a woman accused in a death that has captivated and divided the public. With swirling questions about what really happened, the story raises doubts about the investigation a…
Life is a simulation and John sees hexagons - NMR #82
John is convinced we're living in a simulation because he hallucinates. SUBSCRIBE TO SHAKEN AND DISTURBED ON YOUTUBE! Watch and listen to this and every other episode several days early on Patreon! Patreon members can join us during our …
The Death of Lorenzen Wright - #194
Former NBA player Lorenzen Wright was found dead under mysterious circumstances, sparking a case that captivated the nation. In this episode, we explore the timeline, key players, and chilling twists that kept investigators searching for an…
House of Justice (Flashback #153)
We're taking a break this week (a Spring break if you will!) and will be back with all new episodes next week! This episode aired in March of 2024. This is the true crime story of the perplexing disappearance of Carolyn Muncey from her hom…
John won't stfu about Lady Gaga's new album - NMR #81
John loves the new Lady Gaga, further confirming he is in fact a gay. Daryn got to hang out and work with Dwyane Wade while eating $19 strawberries. SUBSCRIBE TO SHAKEN AND DISTURBED ON YOUTUBE! Watch and listen to this and every other ep…
Did An Alligator Eat Her Husband? - #193
When devoted husband and father Jerry Michael Williams vanished during a solo hunting trip on a Florida lake, authorities suspected a tragic accident—but something didn’t add up. As years passed and new evidence surfaced, the case took a sh…
The Lonely Hearts Killer - #192
Harvey Glatman was a serial predator who targeted aspiring models in the 1950s, luring them with promises of fame. Beneath his unassuming exterior, he meticulously documented his crimes, capturing eerie photographs of his victims. His distu…
Daryn adopted a Pixar lamp - NMR #80
Daryn updates us on her adorable puppy Snoopy. John got distracted by a milkshake. Get 10% off your order at BareBearSoapWorks.com using code SHAKEN at checkout! SUBSCRIBE TO SHAKEN AND DISTURBED ON YOUTUBE! Watch and listen to this and …
Making 'The Curious Case of Natalia Grace' with Showrunners Shannon Evangelista and Tim McConville - #191
Ever wonder what it was like making one of the biggest true crime documentaries of the last several years? Shannon Evangelista and Tim McConville are showrunners on shows like "The Curious Case of Natalia Grace," and the spinoff series "The…
"American Murder: Gabby Petito" Netflix Documentary Reaction - #190
The Netflix documentary "American Murder: Gabby Petito" explores the heartbreaking case that captivated the nation, unraveling the events leading up to her tragic disappearance and the investigation that followed. In this episode, we break …
We remodeled our virtual homes - NMR #79
We have new virtual homes. Daryn has already been to urgent care with Snoopy! SUBSCRIBE TO SHAKEN AND DISTURBED ON YOUTUBE! Watch and listen to this and every other episode several days early on Patreon! Patreon members can join us during…
"American Manhunt: O.J. Simpson" Netflix Reaction - #189
We review the latest Netflix true crime documentary "American Manhunt: O.J. Simpson." Everyone is familiar with the way this case went down, but in this episode, we highlight several facts about this case that even we forgot about. From the…
The Suitcase Murder: The Tragic Case of Sarah Boone and Jorge Torres - #188
Sarah Boone's story is one of tragedy and violence. Once a model citizen, her life spiraled into addiction and abuse, culminating in the shocking death of her boyfriend, Jorge Torres. Police uncovered haunting evidence, including videos of …
Daryn has ANOTHER huge announcement - NMR #78
The dramatic life changing announcements keep coming in for Daryn. Nothing new in John's world. SUBSCRIBE TO SHAKEN AND DISTURBED ON YOUTUBE! Watch and listen to this and every other episode several days early on Patreon! Patreon members …
Christa Pike: Satanic Betrayal - #187
In 1995, Christa Pike became the youngest woman ever sentenced to death row after the brutal murder of Colleen Slemmer in Knoxville, Tennessee. This shocking true crime story dives into Christa’s troubled upbringing, her connection to the J…
Tire Tracks Lead to House of Horrors - #186
When woman after woman continues to disappear in Baton Rouge, Louisiana, only to be found in the most horrific ways, police discover tire tracks that lead them right to one of the most gruesome crime scenes they've ever seen. The man, Sean …
Daryn shares a huge life-changing announcement - NMR #77
It's our first new episode of 2025! We discuss John forgetting to send Daryn's Christmas gift. Daryn checks in amidst the Los Angeles wildfires. And Daryn shares a very personal and exciting update about her life! SUBSCRIBE TO SHAKEN AND D…
Ask Us Anything 2024 Part 2
How would we spend a million dollars? What dead/alive person would we have dinner with? We're back with our final holiday episode, Part 2 of Ask Us Anything! We're back with all new episodes starting next week! Happy 2025! SUBSCRIBE TO SHA…