Episodes
EP 397 - El Paso High School and Mary Ann Murphy
Donna heads to Texas to uncover the eerie legends surrounding El Paso High School — often called the most haunted school in America. From ghostly yearbook photos to sealed-off hallways, she dives into what makes this school a paranormal hot…
Sinister Sightings - EP340
Sinister Sightings are your true crime and true paranormal stories. Every week we read out ones that you've sent in. So prepare to get spooked. Do you have your own Sinister Sighting to share? Email us your stories at aparanormalchicks@gma…
EP 396 - Change Up
Hi ya! So this week is a little different. Donna tried to get sick, again. So, we couldn't leave you hanging. Enjoy a sneak peak into what every is getting on patreon!
Sinister Sightings - 339
Sinister Sightings are your true crime and true paranormal stories. Every week we read out ones that you've sent in. So prepare to get spooked. Do you have your own Sinister Sighting to share? Email us your stories at aparanormalchicks@gma…
EP 395 - Elizabeth Jane Croom Bellamy and Ilse Koch
Donna explores the life of Southern writer Elizabeth Jane Croom Bellamy, whose work reflected the grief and moral struggles of post–Civil War America. Her story reveals a woman navigating loss, legacy, and the expectations of her time. Ker…
Sinister Sightings - EP338
Sinister Sightings are your true crime and true paranormal stories. Every week we read out ones that you've sent in. So prepare to get spooked. Do you have your own Sinister Sighting to share? Email us your stories at aparanormalchicks@gma…
EP 394 - Jaime Feden and Elke Sommer
Kerri covers the disturbing murder of Jaime Rae Feden, whose boyfriend lured her to the Nevada desert and later impersonated her online in a twisted act of deception. Donna shares the eerie story of actress Elke Sommer’s haunted Beverly Hi…
Sinister Sightings - EP337
Sinister Sightings are your true crime and true paranormal stories. Every week we read out ones that you've sent in. So prepare to get spooked. Do you have your own Sinister Sighting to share? Email us your stories at aparanormalchicks@gma…
Sinister Sightings - EP337
Sinister Sightings are your true crime and true paranormal stories. Every week we read out ones that you've sent in. So prepare to get spooked. Do you have your own Sinister Sighting to share? Email us your stories at aparanormalchicks@gma…
EP 393 - Mina "Margery" Crandon and Selena Not Afraid
Donna dives into the strange world of Mina “Margery” Crandon, one of the most famous spiritualist mediums of the 1920s. With claims of séances, ghostly voices, and even some bizarre ectoplasmic displays, Margery captivated audiences and cri…
Sinister Sightings - EP336
Sinister Sightings are your true crime and true paranormal stories. Every week we read out ones that you've sent in. So prepare to get spooked. Do you have your own Sinister Sighting to share? Email us your stories at aparanormalchicks@gma…
EP 392 - Logan Tucker and Robert Johnson
Kerri takes us through the heartbreaking case of Logan Tucker, a young boy whose disappearance and murder shook his Oklahoma community. Donna lightens things up a bit with the fascinating life (and mysterious death) of Robert Johnson, the…
Sinister Sightings - EP335
Sinister Sightings are your true crime and true paranormal stories. Every week we read out ones that you've sent in. So prepare to get spooked. Do you have your own Sinister Sighting to share? Email us your stories at aparanormalchicks@gma…
EP 391 - Ashland Tragedy and Courtney Coco
Donna takes us back to the 1800s with the Ashland Tragedy, a brutal crime that shocked Kentucky and left behind a legacy of fear, public outrage, and vigilante justice. Kerri tells the heartbreaking story of Courtney Coco, a young woman fr…
Sinister Sightings - EP334
Sinister Sightings are your true crime and true paranormal stories. Every week we read out ones that you've sent in. So prepare to get spooked. Do you have your own Sinister Sighting to share? Email us your stories at aparanormalchicks@gma…
EP 390 - Annie Le and Hvaldimir the whale
Kerri dives into the heartbreaking story of Annie Le, a brilliant Yale graduate student whose bright future was tragically cut short by murder. Meanwhile, Donna TRIES to lighten the mood with the unusual tale of Hvaldimir the whale—a frie…
Sinister Sightings - EP333
Sinister Sightings are your true crime and true paranormal stories. Every week we read out ones that you've sent in. So prepare to get spooked. Do you have your own Sinister Sighting to share? Email us your stories at aparanormalchicks@gma…
EP - 389 Cindy Sarro and Shanda Sharer
Donna takes us inside the chilling story of Cindy Sarro and the haunted house that left her questioning what was real and what wasn’t. Kerri covers the heartbreaking case of Shanda Sharer, a twelve-year-old whose life was tragically cut s…
Sinister Sightings - EP332
Sinister Sightings are your true crime and true paranormal stories. Every week we read out ones that you've sent in. So prepare to get spooked. Do you have your own Sinister Sighting to share? Email us your stories at aparanormalchicks@gma…
EP 388 - Mitrice Richardson and Char Man
Kerri takes us through the heartbreaking story of Mitrice Richardson, a young woman whose disappearance in 2009 exposed serious failures by law enforcement and left her family searching for answers. Donna lightens things up with a chillin…
Sinister Sightings - EP331
Sinister Sightings are your true crime and true paranormal stories. Every week we read out ones that you've sent in. So prepare to get spooked. Do you have your own Sinister Sighting to share? Email us your stories at aparanormalchicks@gma…
EP - 387 Jemima Packington and Jasmine Harlee
Donna dives into the quirky world of Jemima Packington, the only known "asparamancer," who predicts the future using asparagus. Her unusual method has made headlines and sparked plenty of curiosity. Kerri covers the shocking case of Jasmin…
Sinister Sightings - EP330
Sinister Sightings are your true crime and true paranormal stories. Every week we read out ones that you've sent in. So prepare to get spooked. Do you have your own Sinister Sighting to share? Email us your stories at aparanormalchicks@gma…
EP 386 - Michelle Castillo and the Foley House Inn
Kerri covers the heartbreaking case of Michelle Castillo, a young mother whose life was cut short in a brutal act of violence. While her death appeared to be suicide, the evidence quickly pointed to murder. Donna takes us to Savannah, Geo…
Sinister Sightings - EP329
Sinister Sightings are your true crime and true paranormal stories. Every week we read out ones that you've sent in. So prepare to get spooked. Do you have your own Sinister Sighting to share? Email us your stories at aparanormalchicks@gma…
EP 385 - Hilary Porter and Philip Markoff
Donna dives into the bizarre and unsettling alien abduction story of Hilary Porter, a woman who claims to have been taken by extraterrestrials multiple times over her life. Kerri tells the story of the so-called Craigslist Killer, Philip …
Sinister Sightings - EP328
Sinister Sightings are your true crime and true paranormal stories. Every week we read out ones that you've sent in. So prepare to get spooked. Do you have your own Sinister Sighting to share? Email us your stories at aparanormalchicks@gma…
EP 384 - Relisha Rudd and the Chelsea Hotel
Kerri covers the heartbreaking story of Relisha Rudd, an 8-year-old girl who vanished from a Washington D.C. homeless shelter in 2014. As the investigation unfolded, disturbing details about the adults in her life and the system that failed…
Sinister Sightings - EP327
Sinister Sightings are your true crime and true paranormal stories. Every week we read out ones that you've sent in. So prepare to get spooked. Do you have your own Sinister Sighting to share? Email us your stories at aparanormalchicks@gma…
EP 383 - Joan Vollmer and Lorenzen Wright
Donna tells us about the exorcism of Joan Vollmer. Joan had a history of mental illness and the chilling story of her death during a makeshift ritual raised questions about faith, mental health, and the line between belief and brutality.  …
Sinister Sightings - EP326
Sinister Sightings are your true crime and true paranormal stories. Every week we read out ones that you've sent in. So prepare to get spooked. Do you have your own Sinister Sighting to share? Email us your stories at aparanormalchicks@gma…
EP 382 = Robin Bledsoe Spielbauer and Museum of Shadows
Kerri takes us back to Amarillo two weeks in a row to cover the story of Robin Bledsoe Spielbauer. She was found murdered on a lonely stretch of Texas road and suspicion quickly turned toward those closest to her. Police quickly learned of …
Sinister Sightings - EP325
Sinister Sightings are your true crime and true paranormal stories. Every week we read out ones that you've sent in. So prepare to get spooked. Do you have your own Sinister Sighting to share? Email us your stories at aparanormalchicks@gma…
EP 381 - Wayside Inn and Brian Deneke
Donna tells us the story of Longfellow's Wayside Inn in Sudbury, Massachusetts. A historic tavern dating back to 1716, was famously immortalized by Henry Wadsworth Longfellow in his Tales of a Wayside Inn. Known as the oldest operating inn …
Sinister Sightings - EP324
Sinister Sightings are your true crime and true paranormal stories. Every week we read out ones that you've sent in. So prepare to get spooked. Do you have your own Sinister Sighting to share? Email us your stories at aparanormalchicks@gma…
EP 380 - Colleen Stan and Pigman Road
Kerri covers a really tough story this week. She tells the kidnapping story of Colleen Stan. While hitchhiking to a friend's house, she was picked up by Cameron and Janice Hooker. The two had a child with them so she trusted it enough to ge…
Sinister Sightings - EP323
Sinister Sightings are your true crime and true paranormal stories. Every week we read out ones that you've sent in. So prepare to get spooked. Do you have your own Sinister Sighting to share? Email us your stories at aparanormalchicks@gma…
EP 379 - Swamp Gas and Terry Lee King
Donna takes us to Michigan where bright, pulsating lights were spotted on more than one occasion. This became a national story and eventually the lights were determined to be swamp gas which thoroughly angered people as they felt they were …
EP 379 - Swamp Gas and Terry Lee King
Donna takes us to Michigan where bright, pulsating lights were spotted on more than one occasion. This became a national story and eventually the lights were determined to be swamp gas which thoroughly angered people as they felt they were …
Sinister Sightings - EP322
Sinister Sightings are your true crime and true paranormal stories. Every week we read out ones that you've sent in. So prepare to get spooked. Do you have your own Sinister Sighting to share? Email us your stories at aparanormalchicks@gma…