Episodes
Hearts Afire (Who the Bleep Did I Marry)
Audrey Mabrey fell in love and married a police detective, but after six years all of that would change. This Week’s Sponsors: Remi - Head to shopremi.com/THINK and use code THINK to save up to 50% off Quince - Go to Quince.com/think for …
True Crime Rundown: The Trial of Luigi Mangione
Ellyn and Joey are coming to you from the road this week as they break down all of the recent happenings in Luigi Mangione's case.
One Night Affair (Who the Bleep Did I Marry)
A horrifying crime was committed in Robin Faulk's small town and she has to confront her husband's dark side. This Week’s Sponsors: Function Health - Learn more and use our link at functionhealth.com/ITHINKNOT Miracle Made - Go to trymir…
Tour Dates + Updates!
Joey and Ellyn are popping in for just a quick rundown on the upcoming tour dates before they head out on the road, plus an overview on Apple subscription.
Love Sick (Who the Bleep Did I Marry)
Donna met a good-looking Jim in college and they instantly clicked; after two decades of marriage and two beautiful children, Donna discovers a shocking secret about her husband that threatens to destroy everything. This Week’s Sponsors: B…
True Crime Rundown: The Trial of Bryan Kohberger
On this episode of the Rundown, Joey and Ellyn switch gears to the recent sentencing in a new trial. Bryan Kohberger was sentenced to life in prison without parole for the murders of four University of Idaho students. Listen and break it al…
The Doctor and The Bunny (Playboy Murders)
As a Playboy Bunny, Jackie Hendrickson is forbidden from fraternizing with her customers; Atlanta plastic surgeon Dr. Warren Brown is impossible to resist, and their illicit affair sets off a deadly chain of events. This Week’s Sponsors: F…
Horror in the Hamptons (Playboy Murders)
Actress Melonie Haller is poised for stardom after appearing in the television series "Welcome Back, Kotter" and a pictorial in the March 1980 edition of Playboy; eager for her next role, she goes to a party in the Hamptons that takes a vio…
True Crime Rundown: The Trials of Diddy and Karen Read Part 9
Ellyn is joined by Emily Pelphrey, a former criminal prosecutor at the County, State and Federal levels. Ellyn does a quick Karen Read update before they dive into the Diddy trial and the recent verdict reached. Emily notably was the prosec…
The Centerfold and the Serial Killer (Playboy Murders)
Kerissa Fare is thrilled to be September 2000's Playmate of the Month; just as the magazine is about to hit newsstands, a mysterious man from her past becomes a suspect in multiple murders, and investigators want to talk to her. This Week’…
True Crime Rundown: The Trials of Diddy and Karen Read Part 8
Detective Sergeant Anthony Rykowski joins Ellyn and Joey for a discussion about Karen Read, corruption in law enforcement, police ethics and more! We first met Anthony when we were recapping "Disappeared". He was featured on Episode 111 - L…
Bonus from Patreon - Every Shot He Took, I Felt It (How I Caught My Killer)
As part of our dark week due to the holiday, we have a special surprise for you all! This is a bonus episode, previously exclusive to our Patreon page and originally published on 2/27/25. Join now and get 9 episodes of How I Caught My Kille…
True Crime Rundown: The Trials of Diddy and Karen Read Part 7
On this episode of the rundown, both the DIDDY trial and the KAREN READ trials come to an end. We talk closing statements in the Diddy trial and all of the post trial circus show activities in the Karen Read trial. The McAlberts caught lyin…
Terror at the Suncoast Club (Playboy Murders)
Panic spreads at the Suncoast Playboy Club when an aspiring photographer turns up brutally murdered right after shooting the annual "Bunny of the Year" contest; the Playboy Bunnies fear their club is a target and that one of them could be n…
Last Dance (Playboy Murders)
Fresh from a breakup, a Playboy casting assistant revels in the L.A. nightlife scene until a wild night out ends in her mysterious death. This Week’s Sponsors: Pacagen - Head to pacagen.com/THINK for an extra 25% off and an exclusive gift …
True Crime Rundown: The Trials of Diddy and Karen Read part 6
So much happens everyday in both trials it's hard to keep up. But the last three witnesses for the defense took the stand and were hot and spicy! We also talk about Alan Jackson's electric closing statements. And we talk about our general c…
Jodi Hildebrandt (Curious Case Of…)
Therapist Jodi Hildebrandt's crusade against masturbation drives a wedge between couples in crisis; she forms a dark alliance with Mormon mommy vlogger Ruby Franke, but a horrifying 911 call exposes the depths of their bizarre beliefs. Thi…
True Crime Rundown: The Trials of Diddy and Karen Read Part 5
Joey and Ellyn go over the past couple days of testimony in the P Diddy and Karen Read trial, including a heartbreaking but important testimony from Diddy‘s ex assistant Mia, as well as in the Karen Read trial the sweetest plow driver you e…
The Orphan Imposter (Curious Case Of…)
Master conman Nicholas Rossi fakes his death to evade justice, adopts new identities and leaves a trail of alleged crimes across continents. This Week’s Sponsors: Wildgrain - Visit wildgrain.com/THINK to get $30 off your first box plus fre…
True Crime Rundown: The Trials of Diddy and Karen Read Part 4
In Rundown 4 - Diddy’s former assistant, Capricorn Clark, takes the stand for a full day worth of (INSANE) testimony. We learn everything Cassie and Kid Cudi told us plus a whole lot more. A FIVE DAY lie detector test???? Yup! Plus! As the …
The Funeral Home of Horrors (Curious Case Of…)
Jon and Carie Hallford's Return to Nature promises care but instead leaves bodies decomposing in filth and provides families with concrete instead of ashes; when investigators arrive, the Hallfords flee, leaving families demanding justice. …
True Crime Rundown: The Trials of Diddy and Karen Read Part 3
Hello DBS! We wanted to start your weekend right with the next episode of TRUE CRIME RUNDOWN! The casual chat that Ellyn and Joey have about the hot topics that are hitting the true crime news. In this episode we will go over the past coupl…
The Girl Who Died Twice (Curious Case Of…)
In 1981, thirteen-year-old Mary Day vanishes and Investigators suspect her stepfather may have killed her, but they never recover her body; decades later, a woman claiming to be Mary appears, stirring suspicions on what happened. This Week…
True Crime Rundown: The Trials of Diddy and Karen Read Part 2
Welcome to this special nighttime surprise! In this week's installment of True Crime Rundown, we cover everything that has happened in the trials of Diddy and Karen Read since last last week through Monday evening. Best to enjoy with a gumm…
True Crime Rundown: The Trials of Diddy and Karen Read
Welcome to the first ever installment of I Think Not’s new weekly mini-series, True Crime Rundown. You will now be able to catch up on the true crime news that Ellyn and Joey are currently hyper fixated on. This week, they cover the latest …
What Lies Beneath (Married to Evil)
When Heidi's alcoholic husband, Chris, goes missing, she searches far and wide to find him, getting help from Chris' wider family; after a missing person's report is filed, police uncover a dark secret hidden in the basement of the marital …
Deadly Delivery (Married to Evil)
A successful Florida family has their American dream shattered when a mysterious figure dressed as a clown shoots a loving mother on her doorstep; the case goes cold for decades until an unexpected break helps bring the killer clown to just…
Home is Where the Nightmare is (Married to Evil)
Jenny and Mike were teen sweethearts but after marrying, Mike begins a campaign of control and violence against his wife and children. Just as Jenny plans to escape her living nightmare, Mike finds out and decides he will do anything to sto…
A Deadly Dose (Married to Evil)
Maria's world shatters when her husband Joel starts an affair; she fights to save their marriage, but Joel refuses to give up his mistress, and Maria's patience runs out; when she threatens divorce, Joel makes a deadly plan to stop her. Th…
Dying for Love (Bizarre Murders)
When a non-smoker is poisoned with a deadly dose of nicotine, it becomes a curious case for investigators. This Week’s Sponsors: ZBiotics - Go to zbiotics.com/think to get 15% off your first order when you use code THINK at checkout. Rem…
Smoking Bun (Bizarre Murders)
When a murderer accidentally leaves his footprint in a hot dog bun that lies next to his victim, he's able to be tracked down. This Week’s Sponsors: IQ Bar - Get twenty percent off all IQBAR products, plus get free shipping. To get your tw…
Counter Punch (Bizarre Murders)
An intended murder victim takes her would-be murderer by surprise and kills him instead as she fights for survival. This Week’s Sponsors: BetterHelp - This episode is sponsored by BetterHelp. Give online therapy a try at betterhelp.com/ith…
Who Done It? (Bizarre Murders)
When a dead body is found outside of a church, it leads detectives into a world of sex, drugs, and Halloween pranks. This Week’s Sponsors: IQ Bar - Get twenty percent off all IQBAR products, plus get free shipping. To get your twenty perce…
Skeleton in the Closet (Bizarre Murders)
A married woman brings another man into her marriage, literally. The man secretly lives in their closet, and eventually he kills the husband. This Week’s Sponsors: HungryRoot - Head to hungryroot.com/ithinknot and use code ITHINKNOT to get…
The Coin Conspiracy (Scam Goddess)
Scam Goddess Laci Mosley lands in Washington to uncover a years-long con at a private mint. Ross Hansen and Diane Erdmann promised golden returns, but greed tarnished their empire, leaving loyal investors shortchanged. This Week’s Sponsors…
The Holy Hustle (Scam Goddess)
Scam Goddess Laci Mosley takes on New York City to expose Bishop Lamor Whitehead. Whitehead built a flashy Brooklyn congregation, streaming his sermons to the world. But as his faith grew, so did his taste for the finer things. This Week’…
The Gig City Grift (Scam Goddess)
Laci Mosley is in Opelika, Ala. to confront scammer Kyle Sandler, who portrays himself as a tech guru who can make Silicon Valley dreams come true; leaving clients with nothing but error 404s. This Week’s Sponsors: Gabb Mobile - Go to Gabb…
The Sideline Scammer (Scam Goddess)
Scam Goddess Laci Mosley journeys to Miami to unravel a con targeting big names in sports. Financial advisor Peggy Fulford promised athletes like Dennis Rodman generational wealth but drained their accounts to fund her lavish lifestyle. Th…
The Horseplay Heist (Scam Goddess)
Digging into the story of Rita Crundwell, who steals $53 million from her town; learning Rita uses the money to fund her lavish equestrian lifestyle, Laci meets the whistleblower who finally reigned in Rita's wild ride. This Week’s Sponsor…
Killer Hookup (Killer in Plain Sight)
After a night of partying, law student Jesse Valencia is found with his throat slashed. He was a free spirit in the college gay party circuit, so there is no shortage of suspects. It appears one of his lovers had a secret to keep. This Wee…