Sugar Coated Murder
Two sisters discussing true crime murders while baking in the kitchen and sharing recipes in a True Crime Comedy Improv podcast.
Episodes
Recipe for Blueberry Almond Pound Cake and the Murders of Richitelli and Altman
It's Karen's turn in the kitchen and she is on a mission to bake her son's birthday cake. As she constructs a gorgeous and delicious Blueberry Pound Cake with an Almond Glaze, Anne lends her perspective on the senseless murders of Emily Ric…
Where is Crystal Rogers, what's going on in Bardstown, and Chocolate Sugar Cookies with Vanilla Icing
While Anne bakes up yummy Chocolate Sugar Cookies in the shapes of Buffalo and Cowboy Boots topped with vanilla icing, Karen unravels the mysterious disappearance of Crystal Rogers, mother of 5. Bardstown, KY, has a handful of unsolved mur…
No Bake Episode with Colucci Courthouse Chronicles
In this episode, the kitchen is closed. Anne and Karen detail their courthouse adventures during the Michael Colucci trial. The bidding is opened on Karen's signed, original courtroom drawing. You can email us at murder.sugarcoated@gmail…
The Victimology of Gregory Rice and a recipe for Millionaire Shortbread
In this very special episode, the sisters welcome author and coach, Liz Bullard! Liz has written many books, some mystery/thriller and some fantasy. She has books for everyone! She currently has a Kickstarter Campaign and can use our supp…
A Deep Dive into the Menendez Brothers and a Recipe for Cinnamon Roll Cruffins
It's Anne's turn in the kitchen and she does not disappoint! She bakes us some delicious Cinnamon Roll Cruffins (https://iambaker.net/cinnamon-roll-cruffins/#wprm-recipe-container-177616). The sisters discuss their fossil hunting adventure …
The ABCs of Evildoers and a Recipe for Low Sugar Sweet Potato Bread
The sisters are finally successful at recording the episode with actual sound! Karen tries out a recipe for Low Sugar Sweet Potato Bread and it turns out fluffy and nutty with warm spices. It would make a delicious breakfast bread! She f…
Recipe for Mini Chocolate Bourbon Bundts and the flipping of a Death Row sentence
Karen performs for Anne. Anne pours strong drinks. Karen and Anne get tipsy. Anne bakes up delicious Chocolate Bourbon Mini Bundt Cakes. We got too tipsy and forgot to taste them during the episode. Karen tells the harrowing tale of a doubl…
Recipe for Pistachio Pound Cake with Cherry Glaze and the cases of Brittney Gregory and Heather Saul
Welcome to our 150th episode!!! It's Karen's turn to bake this week and she doesn't disappoint. She shares the recipe for a festive green Pistachio Pound Cake with Cherry Glaze. First, Karen unpacks the details of the betrayal and murder of…
Doink Doink Doink - Sugar Cookies!
It's our first full video episode! Anne shares her recipe for freshly baked Brown Butter Sugar Cookies. They turned out so yummy! Karen narrates the story of how a psychic in Ohio solved a mystery unraveling in Arizona. This is the case of …
The Murders of McCaffrey and Howard
In this episode, the ovens are off because it is way too hot to cook right now in the Lowcountry! First, Anne Varner unpacks the case of Gayle McCaffrey, who went missing under suspicious circumstances. Listen to see if Gayle ever got the j…
The Killing of Andre` Montgomery and a Baked Alaska recipe
In this new episode, Anne conquers one of her bucket list recipe challenges - Baked Alaska. This one has a chocolatey brownie bottom, topped with creamy mint chip ice cream and sealed under a dome of Swiss Buttercream Meringue. So Delicious…
The mysterious death of Sara Colucci and her husband's retrial and Beth's Best Blondies
Michael Colucci, a Summerville SC jeweler, stands accused of the 2015 murder of his wife, Sara Lynn Moore-Colucci. The original trial ended in a hung jury. Now, after over five years, Colucci is facing a retrial, scheduled to begin on May 1…
Delayed Justice for Justin Lee Turner and a recipe for Meyer Lemon Cupcakes with Vanilla Rum Glaze
Karen covers the case of the Disappearance and Murder of little Justin Lee Turner from Moncks Corner, SC. In celebration of Karen's birthday, Anne bakes scrumptious Meyer Lemon Cupcakes with Vanilla Rum Glaze.  #recipeswap #missingchild #j…
The Blewer Murder and an easy recipe for Tiramisu
Karen whips up a delicious, easy recipe for Tiramisu. This creamy, coffee-spiked dessert is simple and refreshing. Anne presents the darkest day for the family of Marilyn and Bobby Blewer who were food servers at the Iowa State Fair. Indie …
Who Killed Rashawn Berry and a recipe for Banana Cupcakes with Cinnamon Cream Cheese Frosting
The Sugar Sisters are back with a new episode. Anne makes delicious Banana Cupcakes with scrumptious Cinnamon Cream Cheese Frosting. Karen recounts the story of who killed Rashawn Berry and what the motive was. Anne's recipe came from Sally…
Recipe for Strawberry Jelly Roll and Interview with Dr. Kenneth Kinsey part 2
Our interview with Dr. Kinsey continues in this episode. Did a ghost visit Dr. Kinsey? Was he intimidated by Alex Murdaugh at the trial? What did Dr. K think of the Strawberry Cake Roll we served him? These burning questions and more are co…
Recipe for Strawberry Jelly Roll and Interview with Dr. Kenneth Kinsey
In this special episode, Karen and Anne welcome a crime scene expert, weapons expert, trial testified, an equalizer for the prosecution, and a co-star in the Alex Murdaugh murder trial - DR. KENNY KINSEY! In this part 1 of 2, we interview h…
Recap of Gypsy Rose and Dee Dee Blanchard and New Year's Morning Breakfast Casserole
Anne recaps the story of Gypsy Rose Blanchard who was convicted of 2nd degree murder of her mother, Dee Dee. Gypsy has just been granted parole after serving 8 years of her 10-year sentence. Gypsy Rose suffered unspeakable horrors at the ha…
The Disappearance of Amy Robinson and a recipe for Mini Powdered Donut Muffins
Anne bakes up memory-inducing Mini Powdered Donut Muffins that remind the sisters of their youth. These powdery pillows of softness are perfect for Christmas morning. Karen recounts the horrifying details of the kidnapping and torturous kil…
Pilgrim Sandwiches and Iron Mike Malloy
Still stuffed from Thanksgiving, Karen opts to skip the kitchen in this episode and discuss various foods she enjoyed over the holiday. She describes the Pilgrim sandwiches that were her favorite meal. Anne unwinds the twisted case of the d…
Apple Caramel Upside Down Cake and the Heidt Murders
In this episode, Anne bakes up a recipe for Apple Caramel Upside Down Cake and kicks it up with a secret ingredient. Karen unpacks the case of the Heidt murders out of Georgia, where a tight-knit family has a jealous, nefarious member lurki…
Baking Apple Cinnamon Muffin and the Untimely Demise of Officer Quinn Witherspoon
This episode brings a recipe for Apple Cinnamon Muffins from Karen. She bakes up warm, apple-ly treats that smell of cinnamon, toasted pecans, and KillaVanilla. The recipe is from beyondfrosting.com. Anne gives us a case out of Concord, NC,…
Copycat Recipe for a favorite Starbucks drink and the Tagged Murderer
In this episode, Anne shares a copycat recipe that mimicks Starbucks's Caramel Apple Spice drink. Karen introduces a social media app the ladies have never heard of and then recounts the horrendous acts of a guy with too many letters in his…
The Annihilation of the Harper Family and a recipe for Peanut Butter Protein Balls
OctoBoo was an OctoBust so we talk OctoBalls and a murderous OctoBeast in school principal's clothing. Karen shares her recipe for some delicious peanut butter protein balls because we all need more protein! Anne unpacks the tragic story of…
Serial Killer September - The I-5 Killer and a recipe for Count Chocula cookies
Serial Killer September continues with Anne presenting the story of a monster named Randall Woodfield, also known as "The I-5 Killer. There we so may chances to stop this monster, but a broken system enabled him to escalate from a tallywhac…
Serial Killer September - Ivan Milat and a recipe for Butterscotch Puppy Chow
Serial Killer September continues! First, Karen puts her own spin on a recipe for Puppy Chow. As usual, she just cannot leave a recipe alone and has to make it her own. Is it a success, or is it a failure? Next, Anne narrates the horrific c…
Serial Killer September - The Colonial Parkway Murders and a recipe for Brown Butter Rice Crispy Treats
The ladies kick off Serial Killer September with a knockout! First, Anne shares her recipe for Brown Butter Rice Crispy Treats. She gives a great tutorial on how to make brown butter and turns out some fancy mouth treasures. Then, Karen unf…
Victims of Serial Killer Daniel Printz and Boozy Cherry Pie
The sisters try a new bourbon, Anne bakes a Boozy Cherry Pie, and endless inappropriate laughter ensues. Karen offends the US Postal Service, and there is a call for Serial Killer insurance. Karen covers the evil doings of NC/SC Serial Ki…
The Victimization of Nohema Graber and a Blueberry Cobbler Recipe
It's Karen's turn to bake, so she brings out a recipe for a delicious and easy Blueberry Cobbler that she adds Killa Vanilla to. Anne catches us up on True Crime's current events. Then she narrates the heartbreaking story of the victimizat…
The Victimology of Dean Scott Phillips and Pound Cake Redemption
This case was sent to us by a listener named Erin. HI, Erin! Anne reveals a winning recipe for a delicious Pound Cake and redeems herself from an early Pound Cake disaster. Karen unpacks a case that draws eerie similarity to the case of …
A Treacherous Bus Ride and a Recipe for Browned Butter Bourbon Banana Bread
Karen shares a delicious recipe for Browned Butter Bourbon Banana Bread that is a sock knocker offer. It's nutty and banana-ee and did we mention Bourbon? Anne narrates the harrowing story of Tim McLean who boarded a bus in Canada and was…
The Unfortunate Misfortune of Rosalio Gutierrez, Jr and a Recipe for Peach Pie
During this episode, Anne shares the recipe for Perfect Peach Pie from @sallysbakingaddiction. Karen refuses to taste it. Karen tells the sad story of a senseless murder that took away a stand-up guy. Rosalio Gutierrez, Jr. was a popular fa…
Current Events from a Car
You've heard of Carpool Karaoke? Well this isn't it, but it is an episode recorded from the car. Annd and Karen finally get a quick episode recorded! In this episode, they discuss some current court cases in the news. It's great to finally…
Baking Jammy Blueberry Muffins & The Victimology of Brandy Stevens-Rosine
An amazing recipe for Blueberry Jam Muffins that have the ladies jammin'! The victimology of Brandy Stevens-Rosine who will always be remembered as the kind of friend everyone wants to have. It's Anne's turn to bake, so she shares how she m…
The Annihilation of the Haines Family and baking a Pecan Braid
Anne recounts the story of a family's senseless annihilation, and Karen bakes a Pecan Braid using frozen puff pastry. There's a jingle by Josh from Super Familiar with the Wilsons Podcast that reminds us always to clean the knives. Rest in …
Recipe for single serve chocolate cakes and the victim story of Laurel Jean Mitchell
It's Anne's turn to bake, so she presents a delightful recipe for a couple of single-serving chocolate cakes. Of course, she uses Killa Vanilla. As the cakes are baking in their sweet little ramekins, Karen unpacks the story of a smart, kin…
Murder of 2 Billy Whites and Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Chip
The sisters are at it again with hijinx and inappropriate laughter. First there is in-depth uneducated discussion of the ongoing Alex Murdaugh double homicide court case. Karen divulges a great recipe for Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough dip. An…
The Disappearance of AJ Hadsell and a recipe for Chicken Potpie
he Sugar Sisters are happy to be back after a long hiatus! In this episode, Anne bakes a yummy chicken pot pie that is heavenly! Karen covers the story of Angelica 'AJ' Hadsell, who was a freshman at Longwood University in 2015 when she w…
Velvet Vocals, An Old Hollywood Murder, and Caramel Apple Pull Apart Bread
We welcome and friend and fellow indie podcaster, Antonio Palacios of The Cultworthy Podcasts. While Anne bakes an easy and delicious recipe for Caramel Apple Pull Apart Bread, Antonio unleashes his velvety vocals as he details an old Holly…
Spooky Stories - OctoBoo 2022
Happy Halloween, Y'all! In this final OctoBoo series of 2022, it's Karen's turn to break out the spooky stories, but can she complete the task? She talks about creepy stuff happening at the Magnolia Cemetery in Charleston, SC. There are spo…