That Chapter Podcast
That Chapter Podcast is your home for the craziest true crime cases, weirdest plots, and strangest horrors from around the world. That Chapter Podcast has it all, telling you the scariest stories with a little laugh or two along the way.
Episodes
The Sinister Case of Shelby Nealy
Shelby Nealy brought his kids to the in-laws, the Ivanicics, one Christmas. However, where was his wife? Their daughter? Well, he had an excuse for everything, till the excuses ran out and he had to find a more permanent solution. Researc…
Ep.141 - Herbert Mullin, Human Sacrifices to Save the World Pt.2
We're back at it again with part two of the Herb-dog. In episode one we looked at his turbulent early life, and his first vicious kill. Now in part two we go off the rails, and he kills A LOT more people in sinister and tragic ways, includi…
The Yuba County Five
The story of the Yuba County 5 is as much a mystery today as it was 50 years ago when it happened. Why did 5 men seemingly drive miles from where they were supposed to be, when they had places to be and things to do, into the remote wildern…
Ep.140 - Herbert Mullin, Human Sacrifices to Save the World Pt.1
Herbert Mullin did a lot in his young life, travelled, worked, drank and drugged. And he got a lil ole video in his head, from the voices he heard of course, telling him ole Cali is on it's way to the biggest earthquake yet. How to prevent…
The Strange Case of the Weaver Family
Like father like son: this is a tale of two Ward Weavers, Sr & Jr, and both of them became double murderers in completely separate circumstances. What are the odds, huh? HUH!? Send your scary stories to: mikeohhello@gmail.com Instagram: …
Ep.139 - Leonarda Cianciulli, Human Soap Maker
Ole Leonarda was a very strange woman, with some very strange beliefs. With WW2 raging, she would do anything to save her son, and what else is there to do but sacrifice some local women, turn them into soap, and eat them? Sure what else wo…
The Grim Case of Dee Warner
When Dee Warner vanished from her farm in 2021, it seemed inexplicable. Everyone was fearful, except of course, the last person to see her. He though she was just fine. Spoiler alert, not so much. Send your scary stories to: mikeohhello@g…
Thanks for the NIGHTMARE FUEL, Listener Stories Pt.10
Yeah I know these are supposed to be posted on Friday's but I'm travelling so here we are. Thanks for everyone sending a story in! Send your scary stories to: mikeohhello@gmail.com Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/thatchapterpodcas…
The Hunt for Travis Decker
Travis Decker is currently on the run in the wilds of the pacific northwest, after (allegedly) committing the unthinkable: his three young daughters were found murdered near his car, and his campsite. The search has been ongoing for two mon…
Ep.138 - John Haigh, Acid Bath Murderer
John Haigh was a long time crook in England. However, after a few turns in prison he came up with the solution to his problem: no body, no crime. Hence the acid bath murderer, folks! Send your scary stories to: mikeohhello@gmail.com Ins…
The Twisted Case of Karina Cooper
Karina Cooper was alerted to a gunshot in the middle of the night, finding her husband in a horrifying way. However, the police would find something even more disturbing on her Snapchat account. Send your scary stories to: mikeohhello@gma…
Ep.137 - The Evangelista Occult Murders
Benny Evangelist moved to the United States at the turn of the century, after soon became friends with a man who would commit a horrifying act against his own family. Benny moved away, became rich, before his entire family suffered a simila…
The Hunt for Peter Manfredonia
Peter Manfredonia seemed like a regular college kid. However when a man was killed on a lonely road in Connecticut for seemingly no reason, the hunt was on. A hunt that would lead to an abduction, a kidnapping, another murder and a race acr…
Ep.136 - The Lava Lake Murders
In 1924, at a remote trapping cabin in Oregon, a bloody scene was found. But of three trappers who had been there? No sign remained... for a while. The unsolved mystery of the Lava Lake Murders is here, finally, to make your wildest true cr…
The Case of Harmony Montgomery
When police realized no one had seen 5 year old Harmony Montgomery in TWO YEARS, the race was to find her father, Adam, who she was in the custody of. However, Adam had myriad stories as to where she was, ultimately he didn't know either. W…
Ep.135 - Charles Alright, Eyeball Killer
In the early 90's, bodies were found around Dallas. Bodies with their eyeballs missing. A hunt for the killer was on, but who would believe the witnesses? Send your scary stories to: mikeohhello@gmail.com Instagram: https://www.instagra…
The Ibadan Forest of Horrors
In Nigeria, there was a factory. A factory of body parts, that once discovered in 2014, gave this entire area the name the Ibadan Forest of Horrors. Send your scary stories to: mikeohhello@gmail.com Instagram: https://www.instagram.com…
Ep.134 - The Texarkana Moonlight Murders
In Texarkana, a terrifying killer was stalking couples on lover's lanes around the city. Genuinely some horrific acts were committed, until the Texas Rangers sent in their very best man, the WOLF himself. Who did absolutely f**kin' nothing.…
The Case of the Austrian Ripper, Jack Unterweger
Jack Unterweger was a career criminal who in prison released a book. It became a hit, he was a rehabilitated man, and when he was released he became a celebrity. Thing waas, he was only getting started... Send your scary stories to: mikeo…
Ep.133 - The Case of the Servant Girl Annihilator
In Austin, TX, a terrifying serial killer was prowling. Dragging women from their beds and brutally murdering them with an axe in the dead of the night. Whodunnit? Whomdunnit??? Researched by Benj Button Send your scary stories to: mikeoh…
The Horrific Case & Coverup of Otto Warmbier
Otto Warmbier was a young college student, just starting out in life. However, a fateful trip to North Korea would change everything, leaving us horrified and with no many questions to this day. Researched by Benj Button Send your scary s…
YOUR Terrifying Listener Stories, Pt.9
Yeah I know it's a Monday but Keith's on vacation and I dont know how to work the microphone button plweas helwp me i dumb dumn me no work recorder make mouth noise wahh wahh Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
The Disturbing Case of Sade Robinson
When Sade Robinson went on a date with Maxwell Anderson, she never returned. Maxwell, it would turn out, was a monster hiding in plain sight. Send your scary stories to: mikeohhello@gmail.com Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megap…
Ep.132 - The Disturbing Case of the Van Meter Visitor
The Van Meter Visitor was a horrifying event that occurred in Iowa, a strange cryptid appearing in the center of town, witnessed by hundreds of people, and with the town freaking out, the only solution they had was to bury the creature aliv…
Daniel Beckwitt, Secret Murder Tunnels in Bethesda
Daniel Beckwitt was many things: A genius, a crypto millionaire, a hacker, but most of all he was paranoid. So paranoid he dug tunnels under his home in Bethesda, Maryland. Tunnels which would have devastating consequences for one young man…
Ep.131 - The New England Vampire Panic
The late 1800's was a scary time to be in New England. Vampires were on the prowl! The population went into a frenzy, but whom really knows what was going on sure lads feck if i know i only write these descriptions sure any craic with yours…
Hunting John Leonard Orr - Hero Firefighter, Killer Arsonist
John Leonard Orr was king of arson investigators in California: respected, trusted, the guy who knew it all. But he had a dark ole secret, he loved starting the very fires he investigated, leading to murders, and his... very interesting nov…
Ep.130 - Burke & Hare, Serial Killers That Sold Their Victims
Burke and Hare were two of the maddest lads you'll ever hear of. Two Irish fellas who moved to bonnie Scotland, they were real bastards. At first selling the body of a man who died for some sweet moola, then the moola was so good, why not m…
The Active New England Serial Killer Case & Internet Conspiracy
There have been rumours of an active serial killer in New England for months now, is there any truth to it? And why and how can we blame Taylor Swift for all of this? Send your scary stories to: mikeohhello@gmail.com Instagram: https://…
Ep.129 - The Body in the Oven, Finland's Most Disturbing Unsolved Mystery
The murder of Hilkka Saarinen remains to this day one of Finland's most disturbing unsolved mysteries. Is it really unsolved? Technically... Research by Twigs Send your scary stories to: mikeohhello@gmail.com Instagram: https://www.inst…
Stella Nickell, Poisoning a City to Hide a Murder
Stella Nickell was some woman for one woman: married and living in Auburn, WA, when her husband stopped drinking he stopped being fun. And so Stella came up with a plan... it's easy to hide one murder among dozens. Send your scary stories…
Ep.128 - Lizzie Borden, Fall River Axe Murderer
Lizzie Borden, what a gal. Lemme axe you a question, did she really kill her da and step ma? Whom can tell. Research by Benj Button Send your scary stories to: mikeohhello@gmail.com Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/thatchapterpodca…
The Murders of Lauria Bible and Ashley Freeman
When a fire broke out in the trailer teens Lauria Bible and Ashley Freeman were staying out, people feared the worst. However what followed would uncover something darker than anyone could imagine.Send your scary stories to: mikeohhello@gma…
Ep.127 - The Haunting of Borely Rectory
Borely Rectory is one of the most haunted placed in England, with a very weird history, and it was home to even stranger characters, all adding to the legend of the right ole horrible place full of ghouls and sh*t. Research by Benj ButtonSe…
Mark Kilroy & the Matamoros Cult
When Mark Kilroy vanished in Mexico the search was on. However, he came to a more horrifying end than anyone could have imagined. Send your scary stories to: mikeohhello@gmail.com Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/thatchapterpodcast Busi…
Ep.126 - Jeannette DePalma & the Devil's Teeth
When Jeannette DePalma vanished on her way to meet a friend, the search came up empty. However, soon a hand was found, followed by the rest of her surrounded by dead animals, crosses, and satanic symbols in a haunted place called "The Devil…
Robert Ben Rhoades, Truck Stop Killer
Robert Rhoades is the perfect named for a man who drove trucks around America, little did anyone know, however, he had a secret dungeon in the back...Send your scary stories to: mikeohhello@gmail.com Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/tha…
Ep.125 - The Horrifying Tale of Spring-Heeled Jack
SAUCY JACK IS ON THE LOOSE! Spring-heeled Jack was a horrifying person/legend/demon/alien(?) who stalked the streets of London... and beyond 😢Send your scary stories to: mikeohhello@gmail.com Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/thatchapte…
The Case of Madeline Kingsbury
When Madeline Kingsbury vanished, eyes quickly went to her partner Adam Fravel, and Adam's unusual obsession with Gabby Petito. Send your scary stories to: mikeohhello@gmail.com Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/thatchapterpodcast Busine…
Ep.124 - Wade Wilson, Deadpool Killer
Wade Wilson is pretty much the lowest of the low. A man who grew up in a nice regular household, who would go on to become one of the most vile, attention seeking, dumbsh*t killers in recent times. He sucks. Research by Benj ButtonSend your…