Pastor, Wife, and Their Lover: A Murderous Affair

You think a pastor’s house is the safest place on the block, until it isn’t. This episode dives into the 2021 killing of Pastor David Evans in Ada, Oklahoma, and the unraveling of a secret double life: motel meet-ups, a love triangle, and a back door left open on purpose. Prosecutors say Kristie Evans asked her lover Kahlil Deamie Square to come in the night and pull the trigger. She later pled guilty; he did too.We walk you through the timeline, from mission-trip photos to a 911 call, from “unknown intruder” to confession and the claims that made this case even messier: control, humiliation, and coercion behind closed doors. Then we separate receipts from rumor, lay out the sentences, and ask the uncomfortable question: where does consent end and conspiracy begin?What we coverThe affair(s) and how the plan formedThe unlocked door, and the bedroom shootingThe guilty plea, life sentence with parole possibility for Kristie, and life for SquareThe church fallout and the community shock in AdaAllegations of abuse vs. the legal record—what’s proven and what isn’t