Perfectly Paired With...
Each episode of this podcast covers a thoroughly researched story related to all things true crime. Each story, whether about murder, missing persons, cold cases, and or even conspiracy theories is perfectly paired with a delicious beverage that is described and sampled at the beginning then consumed throughout by your two hosts, husband and wife, Jason and Katie. Drink with us as you feed your true crime craving every week.
Episodes
Cruising with Coke and Tequila
Dive into the mysterious world of true crime with our latest podcast episode. Join us as we explore the unsettling disappearance of Annette Meisner from a cruise ship in 2004. With only 20% of the ocean explored, who knows what secrets the …
Aboard the Conquest and Smirnoff Electric Guava
Dive into the mystery of cruise ship disappearances with Perfectly Paired With Podcast. Hosts Jason and Katie unravel tales of the sea, like the baffling case of Kevin McGrath, who vanished without a trace. As Katie shares the story, Jason …
Mystery Connecticut River Valley Killer and Boston Lager
Explore the chilling mysteries of the Connecticut River Valley Killer as we delve into unsolved cases and survivor stories. Join us for a gripping journey.https://amwfans.com/thread/4631/connecticut-river-killer-northeast-1980shttps://unsol…
Dead Bodies Everywhere and Colorado Rum
Explore the mystery of 13 bodies found across New England, and join the debate over a potential serial killer while savoring local Oacis rum made in Loveland, CO.https://news.northeastern.edu/2025/05/13/serial-killer-rumors-new-england/ htt…
Harry Potter and Butterbeer
Explore the haunting tale of Robert Knox, the young actor who brought charm to the Harry Potter series, only to become a victim of the UK's alarming knife crime epidemic. Delve into the tragic events of that fateful night in May 2008, when …
Flight 967 and Cabernet Sauvignon
In 1959, National Airlines Flight 967 crashed in the icy ocean seemingly without explanation. Within four months, one man, Dr. Robert Vernon Spears, who was thought to have been aboard the flight, reappears. His appearance raises not only q…
The Twitter Killer and Sake on Ice
A gripping tale of social media's dark side reveals how a young man exploited vulnerability, leading to tragic outcomes. Discover the unsettling truth.
Ed Gein and Rosé Vodka
Explore the true life of Ed Gein and how his story diverges from the horror movie characters he inspired.
Covina Christmas Massacre and Eggnog and Whiskey
A holiday gathering turns tragic as a family faces unimaginable horror. Explore a chilling tale of revenge, resilience, and the spirit of survival amid chaos. https://www.whittierdailynews.com/2008/12/28/details-continue-to-emerge-in-covin…
Paul Logan and Holiday Ale
Join us as we dive into a chilling Christmas mystery set in 1993. Paul Logan, a devoted father, spent his last day filled with holiday cheer, unaware of the dark fate awaiting him. Discover the twists and turns of this unsolved case paired …
Deplhi Murders and Nordic Mead (Delphi Episode 2)
Explore the depths of a gripping case as we unravel hidden truths, alternative theories, and potential cover-ups in the Delphi murders. Grab your favorite drink, we're sipping on Dansk Mjod Viking Blod, and Join us on this journey. https:…
Deplhi Murders and Indiana Rye Whiskey (Delphi Episode 1)
Explore the depths of a gripping case as we unravel hidden truths, alternative theories, and potential cover-ups in the Delphi murders. Grab your favorite drink, were sipping on Bulleit 95 Rye, and Join us on this journey. https://abcnews.…
Mysterious Death of Amanda Antoni and Canadian Vanilla Whiskey
Join us on our latest podcast episode as we dive into a chilling true crime story set in Canada. We're exploring the mysterious and tragic case of Amanda Antoni, whose life was cut short in a hauntingly bloody scene. As always, we're pairin…
Chris Watts and Pumpkin Beverages Part 3
Explore the chilling final chapter of the Chris Watts saga, delving into manipulation, narcissism, and unexpected twists, perfectly paired with Bird Dog Pumpkin Spice Whiskey (we decided to put it in coffee part way through the episode and …
Chris Watts and Pumpkin Beverages Part 2
This is part two of our Chris Watts series. Start with part one and then come back :) https://www.biography.com/crime/chris-watts-wife-daughters-murder-mistress-confession-timeline https://www.eonline.com/news/1298570/the-unraveling-of-chri…
Chris Watts and Pumpkin Beverages Part 1
Welcome to “Perfectly Paired With...” where chilling tales meet craft beer! In this spine-tingling part one episode, we dive into the horrifying case of Chris Watts, unraveling the dark secrets behind one of America’s most infamous true cri…
The Robison Family Massacre and Whiskey
Tune in to our latest podcast episode where Katie dives into the chilling true crime story of the Robison family murders. On July 22, 1968, a group of women playing bridge near Lake Michigan discovered a foul stench that led to the gruesome…
Ted Bundy and the Deathrow Cocktail: Part 2 (part 1 is with wine)
Welcome to Perfectly Paired With, the podcast where Jason and Katie share captivating stories paired with delicious drinks. In this episode, we continue our exploration of the infamous Ted Bundy. As he moves from Washington to Utah, to Colo…
Ted Bundy and Wine Part 1
Welcome to Perfectly Paired With, a podcast where we explore true crime stories while enjoying a drink. In this episode, we delve into the chilling tale of Theodore Robert Bundy, one of America's most notorious serial killers. From his earl…
Perfectly Paired With... The Disappearance of Anne Burr
Join us as we delve into the intriguing and mysterious case of a missing child. In this episode of the Perfectly Paired With podcast, we explore the story of Anne Burr, a young girl who vanished without a trace from her home in Tacoma, Wash…
Perfectly Paired With... The Lady of the Dunes
Discover the chilling mystery of the Lady of the Dunes in this gripping true crime tale. Join us as we delve into the investigation of her unidentified remains and explore the shocking connections to notorious killers and a famous mob boss.…
Perfectly Paired With... Killed on the 4th of July
After celebrating the 4th of July in 2001, 20-year-old Megan Barosso found herself the target of the Simi Valley Rapist. Listen and drink along as Jason and Katie discuss the terrifying story of a young woman who became the hunted prey of a…
Perfectly Paired With... O.J. Simpson Part 2
In part 2 we are exploring the different theories about the identity of Charlie, the alleged accomplice in OJ Simpson's hypothetical confession.
Perfectly Paired With... O.J. Simpson Part 1
Join us for a gripping true crime story as we explore the infamous case of O.J. Simpson. This story of justice and tragedy will leave you shocked and wanting to know more. And what better way to accompany this captivating tale than with a r…
Perfectly Paired With... Suzanne Morphew Update
An update on a case we covered last year involving Suzanne Morphew.
Perfectly Paired With... The Burger Chef Murders
Join us on Perfectly Paired With as we dive into a chilling true crime story set in Speedway, Indiana. The Burger Chef murders shocked the community in the 1970s, and we'll explore the mysterious circumstances surrounding the disappearance …
Perfectly Paired With... An Arkansas Double Murder
In this episode, Jason and Katie dive into a true crime story that will leave you on the edge of your seat. Join them as they explore the mysterious circumstances surrounding the deaths of two teenage boys and the shocking conspiracy theori…
Perfectly Paired With... Columbine High School Massacre Part 2
Part 2: Introducing the Columbine High School Massacre: a gripping two-part series that delves into the shocking events that changed the lives of students forever. Join us as we explore the childhoods and friendship of Eric Harris and Dylan…
Perfectly Paired With... Columbine High School Massacre Part 1
Part 1: Introducing the Columbine High School Massacre: a gripping two-part series that delves into the shocking events that changed the lives of students forever. Join us as we explore the childhoods and friendship of Eric Harris and Dylan…
Perfectly Paired With... Villisca Axe Murders Part 2
Uncover the chilling mystery of the Villisca Axe Murders in Part 2! Join us as we delve into the shocking details of this unsolved case. Was it the work of an infamous serial killer or something even more sinister? Grab a drink and prepare …
Perfectly Paired With... Villisca Axe Murders Part 1
Part 1 - Welcome to Perfectly Paired With, the podcast where we delve into fascinating, chilling, and twisted stories while enjoying a drink. Join us as we discuss the dark history of Villisca, Iowa, a railway town in 1912. The Moore family…
Perfectly Paired With... A Minnesota Death Trip
Get ready for a thrilling and mysterious episode of our podcast! Join us as we dive into the perplexing case of Brandon Swanson, a college-aged kid who disappeared under strange circumstances in Minnesota. As we uncover the details, we'll b…
Perfectly Paired With... The Alphabet Murders
Get ready for a chilling and mysterious true crime story that will keep you on the edge of your seat. Join us as we delve into the unsolved case of the Alphabet Murders, where three young girls with alliterative names were tragically taken …
Manson, Chaos, and the CIA - Part 2
PART 2: Join us on a mind-bending journey as we delve into a different story of Charles Manson. Discover shocking connections to the CIA and a secret history that will leave you questioning everything. Get ready to be captivated by this gri…
Manson, Chaos, and the CIA - Part 1
Join us on a mind-bending journey as we delve into a different story of Charles Manson. Discover shocking connections to the CIA and a secret history that will leave you questioning everything. Get ready to be captivated by this gripping ta…
Perfectly Paired With... Charles Manson Part 2
Part 2: Dive into the chilling and infamous story of Charles Manson and his family members. This captivating YouTube video explores the life of Manson, from his troubled childhood to his criminal activities and his influence on pop culture.…
Perfectly Paired With... Charles Manson Part 1
Get ready to dive into the chilling and infamous story of Charles Manson and his family members. This captivating YouTube video explores the life of Manson, from his troubled childhood to his criminal activities and his influence on pop cul…
Perfectly Paired With... Mr. Cruel
During the late 80’s and early 90’s, in the suburban areas surrounding Melbourne Australia, a balaclava clad man assaulted and kidnapped young girls. Eventually evolving into murder. Then the unknown man disappeared, taking his identity wit…
Perfectly Paired With... The CIA Takes On Castro
Mongoose was the secret code name for the CIAs attempts to destabilize the political regime of Fidel Castro. Mongoose was unsuccessful in overthrowing Castro but successful in making the CIA and their attempted assassination attempts seem a…
Perfectly Paired With... Satanic Panic
In the 1980s women in Chicago were being hunted by a merciless satanic cult. Sip on a Bloody Mary and listen along as Katie describes these terrible crimes and the evil man behind them. https://www.cracked.com/article_35559_the-ripper-crew-…