Ohio Coal Miner Shot to Death by Married Best Friend He'd Been Having Secret Affair With
Ohio Coal Miner Shot to Death by Married Best Friend He'd Been Having Secret Affair With

Ohio Coal Miner Shot to Death by Married Best Friend He'd Been Having Secret Affair With

September 30, 2025 8:15pm
29:43
0

The source provides excerpts from a true crime narrative detailing the murder of Brad McGarry in Bellaire, Ohio, a tragedy rooted in a forbidden love affair and betrayal. McGarry, an openly gay former hairdresser who became a coal mine foreman, was shot execution-style by his best friend, David Kinney, a married coworker with whom he was having a secret sexual relationship. The episode describes the victim's unconventional life in a conservative Appalachian community and the circumstances leading up to his death in May 2017, when Kinney feared McGarry would expose their affair. Ultimately, Kinney's attempts to stage the crime as a robbery failed, leading to his conviction for aggravated murder and a sentence of life without parole, revealing a story of hypocrisy and the lethal consequences of suppressed identity within the community.Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/murder-files-unsealed--6017387/support.

Episode Details

Duration:29:43
Published:September 30, 2025 8:15pm
File Size:27.2 MB
Type:audio/mpeg

About This Episode

The source provides excerpts from a true crime narrative detailing the murder of Brad McGarry in Bellaire, Ohio, a tragedy rooted in a forbidden love affair and betrayal. McGarry, an openly gay former hairdresser who became a coal mine foreman, was shot execution-style by his best friend, David Kinney, a married coworker with whom he was having a secret sexual relationship. The episode describes the victim's unconventional life in a conservative Appalachian community and the circumstances leadin...

More Episodes

View All →
Continue exploring episodes from this podcast.