On the night of December 11–12, 2003, a silent 911 call led police to a holiday scene turned horrific: Rick (46) and Susie (45) Wamsley found murdered in their Mansfield home amid Christmas decorations and wrapped presents. What looked like a robbery quickly unraveled — nearly six figures in cash remained untouched, no clear sign of forced entry, and shocking forensic traces changed the investigation’s course: a tuft of hair clenched in Rick’s hand, fragments of a broken blue hair clip, bloody traces linked to Andrew’s white Mustang, and bullets that matched rounds recovered from a nearby pond used for target practice. Initial alibis collapsed after DNA from the hair and clip tied Susanna Todano to the scene and her shifting testimony exposed a plot involving Andrew, his girlfriend Chelsea Richardson, and an accomplice who bought the gun.
Episode Details
About This Episode
On the night of December 11–12, 2003, a silent 911 call led police to a holiday scene turned horrific: Rick (46) and Susie (45) Wamsley found murdered in their Mansfield home amid Christmas decorations and wrapped presents. What looked like a robbery quickly unraveled — nearly six figures in cash remained untouched, no clear sign of forced entry, and shocking forensic traces changed the investigation’s course: a tuft of hair clenched in Rick’s hand, fragments of a broken blue hair clip, bloody t...