On Valentine’s Day 2000, under the cover of a raging storm, Shelby’s sweetheart slipped out of the house in the dead of night—and vanished without a trace. In the 25 years since, the small town has been consumed by heartbreak and haunted by suspicion. The whispers never stopped, and neither did the search. Locals still believe that someone—somewhere—knows exactly what happened that night. But the silence has lasted a quarter of a century, and the truth remains just out of reach.
Episode Details
About This Episode
On Valentine’s Day 2000, under the cover of a raging storm, Shelby’s sweetheart slipped out of the house in the dead of night—and vanished without a trace. In the 25 years since, the small town has been consumed by heartbreak and haunted by suspicion. The whispers never stopped, and neither did the search. Locals still believe that someone—somewhere—knows exactly what happened that night. But the silence has lasted a quarter of a century, and the truth remains just out of reach....