What Was That??
What was that?? A bump in the night? A stranger lurking in the dark? Discover hair-raising stories that make you question everything from your sanity to your safety. Join Jazzy and Addi every week as they explore the most disturbing reddit stories and dive into those macabre subjects you all want to know.
Episodes
Ep 49: Ghosts in the Graveyard
What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode Jazzy and Addi look for ghosts in the graveyard. Is it just a rabid fox? Or is it something FAR more sinister?? Tune in to find out!Follow our subreddit at…
Ep 48: Back Woods
What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode Jazzy head out to the back country for some back wood haunts. Is it just a strange dream after one too many pints of whiskey? Or is it something FAR more s…
Ep 47: In Deep Water
What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode, Jazzy and Addi dive head first into some terrifying tales of the sea. Is it just a simple Manatee? Or is it something FAR more sinister?? Tune in to find …
Ep 46: Scary School Stories
What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode, Jazzy and Addi reminisce on the old days and get into some scary school stories. Is it just an old hobby room? Or is it something FAR more sinister?? Tune…
EP 45: Living for the Hope of it All
What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode, Jazzy and Addi talk situationships with redditors who truly are living for the hope of it all. Is it just salt air and rust on your door? Or is it somethi…
Ep 44: Family Matters
What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode, Jazzy and Addi take a look at some frightening family dynamics. Is it just a family who got lost in the woods? Or is it something FAR more sinister?? Tune…
Ep 43: Birthday Bash Pt. 2
What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode, Jazzy and Addi celebrate Addi’s birthday with some birthday tales that are better left forgotten. Is it just a douchey boyfriend who reaaaally wants a PS5…
Ep 42: Birthday Bash Pt. 1
What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode, Jazzy and Addi celebrate Jasmine’s birthday with some bizarre birthday tales. Is it just a sick cat? Or is it something FAR more sinister?? Tune in to fin…
Ep 41: Summerween
What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode, Jazzy and Addi celebrate Summerween with some twisted summer camp stories. Is it just a spooky fireside tale? Or is it something FAR more sinister?? Tune …
Ep 40: Malicious Mammals
What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode, Jazzy and Addi distinguish some animalistic humans. Is it just a guy who loves haunted houses? Or is it something FAR more sinister?? Tune in to find out!…
Ep 39: HeartBreak Special
What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode, Jazzy and Addi check in to the HeartBreak Hotel. Is it just a bad break up with your ex that has questionable literacy skills? Or is it something FAR more…
Ep 38: Just Renaissance Tings
What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode, Jazzy and Addi travel back in time to the Renaissance period. Is it just an ominous egg? Or is it something FAR more sinister?? Tune in to find out!Follow…
Ep 37: Cursed Items
What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode, Jazzy and Addi join the cult of the Labubu and talk about cursed items. Is it just an ugly little keychain?? Or is it something FAR more sinister?? Tune i…
Ep 36: Do you really have to ask??
What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode, Jazzy and Addi answer reddits biggest question, Am I the Asshole? Is it just carbon monoxide poisoning?? Or is it something FAR more sinister?? Tune in to…
Ep 35: Cannot Compute
What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode, Jazzy and Addi talk tech. Is it just a ghost in the machine?? Or is it something FAR more sinister?? Tune in to find out! (It is in fact, something far m…
Ep 34: If I had known any better
What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode, Jazzy and Addi speculate on what could have been. Was it just an awkward first date?? Or is it something FAR more sinister?? Tune in to find out!Follow ou…
Ep 33: Wedding Hells
What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? None of the above! On this episode the girlies celebrate Addi’s engagement!! For this celebratory episode Jazzy and Addi dive into Wedding Reddits, with a twist. Was it ju…
Ep 32: Don't Worry, I'm a Professional
What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode of “What Was That??” Jazzy and Addi seek professional help. Was it just a couple of curious college girls?? Or is it something FAR more sinister?? Tune in …
Ep 31: Seeing is Believing
What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode of “What Was That??” Jazzy and Addi find out if seeing really is believing. These redditors swear they know what they saw. Was it just your mom grabbing a …
Ep 30: Well, That was weird...
What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode of “What Was That??” Jazzy and Addi get into some weird sh**. Could it just be a ghost getting freaky? Or is it something FAR more sinister?? Tune in to fi…
Ep 29: Could have Been, Would have Been
What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode of “What Was That??” Jazzy and Addi think about what could have been. Could it just be a failed swinger attempt? Or is it something FAR more sinister?? Tun…
Ep 28: Terrifying Travels
What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode of “What Was That??” Jazzy and Addi take some time to decide if the trip is actually worth taking. Is the guy on the bus just making friends? Or is it some…
Ep 27: Are you KIDding Me??
What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode of “What Was That??” Jazzy and Addi connect with Redditors with troublesome childhood tales. Is it just an imaginary friend? Or is it something FAR more si…
Ep 26: Dream a Little Dream of Me
What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode of “What Was That??” Jazzy and Addi explore the hidden meanings of nightmares. Is it just childhood trauma? Or is it something FAR more sinister?? Tune in …
Ep 25: I'm a Creep, I'm a Weirdo
What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode of “What Was That??” Jazzy and Addi shift their perspective by diving into the other side of r/Lets Not Meet stories. Maybe it’s just a group with an….inte…
Ep 24: The Unluck of the Irish
What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode of “What Was That??” Jazzy and Addi celebrate St. Patricks Day! For this Holiday special, enjoy the reddit stories, with a side of Irish Folklore. Is it ju…
Ep 23: Endorphins Make People Happy
What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode of “What Was That??” Jazzy and Addi focus on the G in GTL. Is it just a chad triggering the Lunk Alarm?? Or is it something FAR more sinister?? Tune in to …
Ep 22: Creature Feature
What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode of “What Was That??” Jazzy and Addi catch a midday matinee for a Creature Feature. Is it just a normal deer?? Or is it something FAR more sinister?? Tune i…
Ep 21: Don’t Make Unnecessary Journeys
What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode of “What Was That??” Jazzy and Addi decide the path less traveled is not worth it. In fact, no unnecessary journey is worth it. Stay home. Is it simply a m…
Ep 20: You've Got Mail
What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode of “What Was That??” Jazzy and Addi pick apart parcel services. Is it just a neighbor trying to drop off a package?? Or is it something FAR more sinister??…
Ep 19: A Love Letter to Zak Bagans
What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode of “What Was That??” Jazzy and Addi embark on another Ghosts Adventure filled with haunted houses and love letters to Zak Bagans. Are there simply things i…
Ep 18: Clowning Around
What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode of “What Was That??” Jazzy and Addi dive in to Jazzy’s worst fear and Addi’s deepest desire, clowns. Is it just a guy named Jared wearing makeup pulling a …
17: You've Got A Friend in Me
What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode of “What Was That??” Jazzy and Addi talk all things friendship. Did you just make a new BFF?? Or did you accidentally join a cult?? Tune in to find out! Fo…
16: Are You Gaslighting Me??
What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode of “What Was That??” Jazzy and Addi attempt to figure out what’s real and what’s just a figment of our imagination. Is it simply a girl in need of therapy?…
15: New Year, New Dreams
What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode of “What Was That??” Jazzy and Addi take a trip to Slumberland. Is it simply a scary dream?? Or is it something FAR more sinister?? Tune in to find out! Fo…
14: A Namahage's New Year
What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode of “What Was That??” Jazzy and Addi ring in 2025 with some spooky superstitions. Is it just a REALLLLLY long horse?? Or is it something FAR more sinister??…
13: A Very Krampus Christmas
A Very Krampus Christmas What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode of “What Was That??” Jazzy and Addi celebrate Christmas by diving into the lore of holiday favorites, Krampus and Belsnickel. Is t…
12: Further Into the Forest
What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode of “What Was That??” Jazzy and Addi venture out to the forest to look for monsters. Is it just Sasquatch?? Or is it something far more sinister?? Tune in t…
11: Mama, a man behind you...
What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode of “What Was That??” Jazzy and Addi are on the lookout for those suspicious men hiding in the night. Is it just a confused and clueless man?? Or is it some…
10: Home for the Haunted-days
What Was That?? A bump in the night? A creature lurking in the dark? On this episode of “What Was That??” Jazzy and Addi set some boundaries with house ghosts. Is it just a story from Grandpa?? Or is it something far more sinister?? Tune in…