Friends Who Crime
Friends Who Crime is a lighthearted true crime podcast where host Brynn brings on a different friend each episode to dive into a new case. Brynn handles the research and storytelling, while her guest reacts with commentary and humor. The show focuses on remembering the victims for who they were, all while maintaining an engaging and fun dynamic between Brynn and her friends.
Episodes
Ep. 30: Boulder Jane Doe
This week, Maggie & I chat about the case of Boulder Jane Doe- a mystery that remained unsolved for years until a chance happening knocks it wide open again. It's a truly amazing journey. Boulder Jane Doe AKA Dorothy Gay Howard. Give this t…
Ep. 29: Texas Cryptids
This week on Friends Who Crime, I'm taking a break from human-related mayhem to dive into the truly bizarre and wild world of cryptids. I'm joined by my fantastic guest, Devon, as we explore some of the weirdest and wildest legends right he…
Ep. 28: Gene Thurnau & Bob Peterson
This week it’s just me, myself, and I, so buckle up for a solo episode of Friends Who Crime! Things get a little darker without a guest to banter with, but hey, sometimes that’s just the vibe. Moving forward, my plan is three episodes a mon…
Ep. 27: Betsy & Russ Faria
This week on Friends Who Crime, Morgan joins me as we dive into the wild, twisted story of Pam Hupp — a case that’s equal parts unbelievable and infuriating. We’ll unpack the suspicious death of Betsy Faria, the bizarre murder of Louis Gump…
Ep. 26: Phoebe Hansjuk
A short and sweet episode about the death of Phoebe Hansjuk. Was it an accident? Or something far more sinister? If you want a deeper dive, here are some places you can go: Phoebe's family's website My recommendation: Morbid's podcast epis…
Ep. 25: The Buddhafield Cult
I’m joined by my friend Andy—who you may remember from a previous episode—as we dive into the wild and disturbing story of the Buddhafield cult. Led by a Speedo-wearing ex-actor turned spiritual guru, this cult promised enlightenment but de…
Ep. 24: Dorothy Eggers
On this episode, Jessica and I delve into the shocking 1945 murder of Dorothy Eggers, a case that proves even the meekest men can harbor unimaginable darkness. Discover how a seemingly mild-mannered husband committed a brutal act of dismemb…
UPDATE: The Idaho College Murders
SURPRISE! A follow-up to episode 12, Blaine and I sit down to discuss the new updates in the Idaho College Murders case. With a plea deal in place, sentencing is set for late July. The day after we recorded this, the judge on the case lifte…
Ep. 23: Rebecca Zahau
This week, I'm flying solo to bring you a deep dive into one of the most perplexing cases I've ever encountered: the confounding death of Rebecca Zahau. Found nude, bound, and hanging from a balcony at the historic Spreckels Mansion, her de…
Ep. 22: Maura Murray
Join us on Friends Who Crime as we unravel the perplexing disappearance of Maura Murray. In 2004, this 21-year-old nursing student vanished after a car crash on a desolate New Hampshire road, leaving behind a scene riddled with conflicting …
Ep. 21: The Attic Lovers
On this episode of Friends Who Crime, Ben joins me to explore a case so audacious, it sounds like fiction: the murder of Fred Oesterreich. We'll uncover the shocking truth behind his death, involving his "naughty vamp" wife Dolly and her te…
Ep. 20: Carrie Olson
Join Alyssa and I as we dive into the murder of Carrie Olson. A beautiful life cut short by a man who didn't treat her right. Excuse our silliness (or don't). Hopefully you laugh along with us. Sources Carrie Olson | Family And Death Caus…
Ep. 19: The I-35 Killer
Egg (yes, Egg) and I discuss FWC's first serial killer case: the I-35 Killer. He operated in Texas and paid for it at the end- despite glaring missteps from the penal system. Sources https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Larry_Eyler  https://en.…
Ep. 18: Billy Milligan & D.I.D.
This week, I have Kaity back on the podcast! She's a perfect guest for the case of Billy Milligan. Milligan suffered from D.I.D. and his crimes were horrific. Kaity and I dive into how D.I.D. played into his crimes and his later acquittal. …
Ep. 17: The Keddie Cabin Murders
This week on FWC, my dad, Kurtis, joins me as we unravel the chilling and perplexing Keddie Cabin Murders, a quadruple homicide that has haunted a small California mountain town for over four decades. In 1981, a horrific scene was discovere…
Ep. 16: The Murder of Selena
This week, my bestie Morgan joins me as we unravel the tragic, yet utterly wild, story of Selena Quintanilla's murder. We're diving deep into the Queen of Tejano's rise to superstardom and the shocking betrayal that cut her life short. Expe…
Ep. 15: Keep Austin Haunted 2
Gather 'round for our second special "campfire stories" edition! This week, I'm joined by the one and only Neiko as we delve into the chilling tales of Austin, Texas, from the haunted Littlefield House on UT campus to the restless spirits o…
Ep. 14: The Disappearance of Brian Shaffer
This week on Friends Who Crime, I’m joined by my friend Christian to unravel one of the most haunting missing persons cases I’ve ever researched: the 2006 disappearance of Brian Shaffer. Brian was a 27-year-old med student who seemed to van…
Ep. 13: The Baker Case
In this solo episode, Brynn dives deep into the mysterious 2006 death of Kari Baker, a beloved teacher and pastor’s wife whose apparent suicide unraveled into a chilling murder case. As the layers peel back, listeners follow the relentless …
Ep. 12: The Idaho College Murders
Four young lives, a quiet college town, and a crime that shocked the nation. In this episode, my brother Blaine joins me as we unravel the chilling details of the Idaho College Murders and the arrest of Bryan Kohberger. We dig into the time…
Ep. 11: Toni Henthorn
This week, my friend James joins me to talk about the chilling and tragic death of Toni Bertolet Henthorn, a beloved doctor who fell to her death during what was supposed to be a romantic anniversary hike. But as we dig deeper, it becomes c…
Ep. 10: The Blood Countess, Elizabeth Báthory
​In this TENTH episode of Friends Who Crime, I’m joined by my little brother, Logan, as we delve into the chilling legend of Elizabeth Báthory, the Blood Countess. Together, we explore the gruesome tales of her alleged crimes, the political…
Ep. 9: The Girl In The Barrel
In this episode of Friends Who Crime, I'm joined by friend Savanna to dive into the chilling, decades-old mystery of Reyna AngĂ©lica MarroquĂn. When a sealed barrel is discovered in a Long Island crawl space, the horrifying secret inside unr…
Ep. 8: The Hatchet Wielding Hitchhiker
In this episode of Friends Who Crime, Brynn is joined by Don to unravel the wild, bizarre, and tragic case of the Hatchet Wielding Hitchhiker, Caleb Lawrence McGillvary. What started as a viral internet hero moment quickly spiraled into a s…
Ep. 7: Keep Austin Haunted
This week on Friends Who Crime, we’re diving into the haunted history of Austin, TX, with two of its most infamous paranormal hotspots: The Driskill Hotel and The Clay Pit. From ghostly brides and eerie paintings to spirits lingering in an …
Ep. 6: GUBU
In this episode, we delve into the infamous Malcolm MacArthur case, a chilling double murder that rocked Ireland in 1982 and led to the coining of the term "GUBU" (Grotesque, Unbelievable, Bizarre, and Unprecedented). We'll explore the shoc…
Ep. 5: The Coffee Killer
In this episode of Friends Who Crime, I’m joined by my friend Braden to unravel the chilling case of Mirna Salihin. What was meant to be a casual coffee date ended in a shocking murder, leading to one of Indonesia’s most controversial trial…
Ep. 4: Rebecca Schaeffer
In this episode, we delve into the tragic murder case of Rebecca Schaeffer, a promising young actress whose life was abruptly taken by an obsessed fan. I'm thrilled to have my mom, Katherine, join me as we explore the personal and cultural …
Ep. 3: The Chowchilla Kidnapping
Step back to 1976 and uncover the chilling events of the Chowchilla kidnapping—a day when a peaceful, small-town morning turned into a nightmare. In this episode, Cortney and I trace the timeline of that fateful day, explore the impact on a…
Ep. 2: The Unsolved Murder of Donna Doll
In this episode of Friends Who Crime, I’m joined by my friend, Andy, as we dive into the bizarre and unsettling unsolved murder of Donna Doll. In 1970, the quiet college town of DeKalb, Illinois, was rocked by the mysterious death of the NI…
Ep. 1: Ryan Poston & Shayna Hubers
In the very first episode of Friends Who Crime, Brynn is joined by her friend Kaity to dive into the shocking case of Ryan Poston’s murder. They unravel the toxic relationship between Ryan and Shayna Hubers, the chilling 911 call, Shayna’s …
Friends Who Crime Trailer
In this Friends Who Crime trailer, host Brynn introduces the podcast, sharing her love for true crime and the idea behind the show. Each episode features a different friend reacting to a case Brynn has researched, blending storytelling with…