I've Got Something To Tell You
Remember sitting around a campfire with your best friend, holding a flashlight under your chin, trading the wildest, creepiest stories you’ve ever heard? Or texting your friend “OMG, I’ve got something to tell you” and getting back “TELL ME EVERYTHINGGGG”—this podcast is THAT. Tell US something! Send your stories to igsttystories@gmail.com
Episodes
Episode 37: LIVE SHOW at Jarrod’s: The Amityville Horror
Our first LIVE SHOW!! Recorded live at Jarrod’s Coffee in Mesa, this episode dives into the real story behind The Amityville Horror. Colleen and Tayler trace the 1974 DeFeo family murders at 112 Ocean Avenue in Amityville, Long Island, a…
Episode 36: Afternoon Seance
In this chilling episode, Colleen dives into the disturbing true story of Dean Corll, infamously known as “The Candy Man,” whose crimes in the 1970s left Houston shaken. Then, Tayler takes us to Harrisville, Rhode Island, to explore the hau…
BONUS EPISODE 17: Short Stories ft. Skinwalker Expert Kilee
Get ready for another bonus episode, where Tayler and Colleen tell stories they pull from the tops of their noggins, and from the eerie depths of reddit. And in this episode, we have another skinwalker encounter story from Kilee! Grab a bla…
BONUS EPISODE: Spirit Box at Jarrod's Coffee
Back by popular demand — we got a whole lot spookier this week! We packed up our gear and headed to the famously haunted Jarrod’s Coffee in Mesa for a special bonus episode. Armed with our spirit box, we tried to make contact with whoever m…
Episode 35: Speak Of The Devil
This week, Colleen and Tayler dive into not one, but two chilling legends of true crime and folklore. Colleen takes us inside the twisted world of Ed Gein — the quiet Wisconsin farmer whose farmhouse of horrors shocked the world and inspire…
Episode 34: Driven Underground
On July 15, 1976, a summer school bus in Chowchilla, California, vanished with 26 children and their driver. Hours later, the bus was found abandoned — the kids and Ed Ray were gone without a trace. What followed was one of the largest chil…
Episode 33: Cemetery Masquerade
This week on I’ve Got Something To Tell You, Tayler guides us through the eerie legends of Bachelor’s Grove, Chicago’s famously haunted cemetery where phantom cars, vanishing houses, and ghostly mourners still roam. Then Colleen pulls us ac…
Episode 32: Dolls and Does
This week on I’ve Got Something to Tell You, we’re diving into both true crime and the paranormal. Colleen unpacks the haunting case of Tent Girl—a young woman discovered in a canvas bag off a Kentucky roadside in 1968, whose identity remai…
BONUS EPISODE 16: Short Stories
On this bonus episode, Colleen and Tayler talk near death experiences, ouija board stories + a personal one! And a true crime involving murder by mushrooms. Get cozy, and tune in! Got a scary story? Email us at IGSTTYstories@gmail.com
Episode 31: Davy Jones and Dial Tones
This week, Colleen dives into the chilling and still-unsolved case of Cindy James, a nurse from British Columbia who reported years of stalking, threatening phone calls, and terrifying attacks before her mysterious death in 1989. Was Cindy …
BONUS EPISODE 15: Short Stories
In this bonus episode, we swap haunted house Reddit stories, dig into the eerie world of sleep paralysis, and Tayler shares a personal scary story you won’t forget. Get cozy, light a candle, and join us for a mix of chills and cozy vibes. G…
Episode 30: Chutes and Hammers
Big Ed. Bigger body count. Colleen dives into the chilling crimes of Edmund Kemper, the towering “Co-Ed Killer” who still haunts criminal psychology. Then Tayler takes us deep into the haunted halls of Waverly Hills Sanatorium — ghosts, dea…
BONUS EPISODE 14: Short Stories
Tayler and Colleen share creepy haunted house stories from Reddit—from footsteps in empty hallways to spirits that won’t move on—before diving into the mysterious twists of the Wayfair Furniture Conspiracy, and a story about a man who was a…
Episode 29: The Reptilian Agenda
In this episode, we dive deep into the strange and unsettling world of reptilian conspiracies—from ancient shapeshifters hiding among us to modern claims of mind control. We explore the wild theories that link reptilians to government, medi…
Episode 28: Paranormal Esp-Tea-onage
The Belmez Faces + Alexander Litvinenko: This week on I’ve Got Something To Tell You, we’re steeping a blend of ghosts and espionage—and yes, it’s as wild as it sounds. Tayler kicks things off in a small Spanish village where a woman’s kitc…
BONUS EPISODE 13: Short Stories
In this eerie episode, Tayler shares chilling tales about a man secretly hiding in a house, a cackling witch lurking in the basement, and a ghost who just might be playing with a dog. Colleen brings a firsthand account straight from her mom…
Episode 27: U.F.Ommms
This week on I've Got Something To Tell You, we’re giving you UFOs and our very first cult—and yes, it’s as chaotic as it sounds. Tayler takes us to Rendlesham Forest, where a group of U.S. Air Force members stationed in England stumbled in…
BONUS EPISODE 12: Short Stories
In this cozy (but creepy) bonus episode, Tayler and Colleen dive into spine-tingling stories pulled straight from Reddit — and a few unsettling ones from the tops of their own noggins. From eerie encounters to unexplainable moments, they co…
Episode 26: Stephen King Lives
Tayler takes us to the famously haunted Stanley Hotel (yes, that Stanley Hotel) where ghosts don’t just linger—they straight-up make themselves at home. Meanwhile, Colleen dives into one of the most horrifying true crime stories ever told o…
BONUS EPISODE 11: Short Stories
Mimic & Doppelgänger Reddit Stories + Serial Killer Accidental Interview + Relay Race Aggression This bonus episode dives into the kind of stories that make you question what you’re really hearing… and who’s really there. From eerie voices …
BONUS EPISODE 10: Short Stories
In this delightfully creepy bonus episode, we’re serving up strange stories that’ll have you side-eyeing your reflection. We kick things off with mirror tales—think portals to other realms, reflections acting on their own, and that uneasy f…
Episode 25: The Demonic Infestation of Annabelle
In this solo episode, Tayler dives into the infamous story of Annabelle—the haunted doll that’s been locked away for decades in the Warrens’ Occult Museum. From her disturbing beginnings as a gift to a nursing student, to the violent parano…
Episode 24: My La Llorona
In this chilling episode of I've Got Something To Tell You, we delve into the haunting legend of La Llorona, the weeping woman whose ghostly wails have terrified generations across Latin America. Is it just a story to keep children in line,…
BONUS EPISODE 9: Short Stories ft. Skinwalker Expert Kilee
Grab a blanket, get cozy, and join us for another bonus episode filled with creepy tales from Reddit and our own eerie memories. We kick things off with a chilling skinwalker encounter as told by Kylie on recording (yes, actual audio 👀), d…
Episode 23: Showdowns & Lowdowns
Tombstone, AZ + The Death of Kim Wall In this thrilling episode, Tayler and Colleen tackle tales of the untamed and the unimaginable. First, we saddle up and head to Tombstone, Arizona—a Wild West town where gunfights and ghost stories coll…
Episode 22: The Fresh Princesses Of Bel Scare
The Bellaire House and Survival of Lisa McVey + Serial Killer Bobby Joe Long: Ready for chills and inspiration? This episode takes you inside the Bellaire House, one of the most haunted places in America, where dark secrets and restless spi…
BONUS EPISODE 8: Short Stories
In Bonus Episode 8, Tayler and Colleen are back with another round of eerie short stories pulled from Reddit and their own unsettling memories. This time, we’re diving into tales of doppelgängers, mimics, poltergeist activity, and chilling …
Episode 21: Doppelgängers And Death By Jazz Hands
Dopplegangers & Mimics + The Axeman of New Orleans: In this spine-chilling episode, Tayler and Colleen dive into the world of the uncanny and the unsettling. First up: doppelgängers and mimics—those eerie entities that look and sound just l…
BONUS EPISODE 7: Short Stories
In Bonus Episode 7, Tayler and Colleen dive into a collection of eerie short stories pulled from Reddit and some pulled from the tops of our noggin that are guaranteed to give you chills. From unsettling faerie encounters, to terrifying tal…
BONUS EPISODE 6: Short Stories
In this unfiltered bonus episode, Tayler and Colleen dive into a mix of eerie stories pulled from both Reddit and the depths of their own memories. We start with the disturbing world of false confessions and how easily truth can get twisted…
Episode 20: Borden Bloodlines & Spooky Sh*t
Episode 20: Lizzie Borden – Did She Really Do A Pear Of Murders?? For our 20th episode, we’re diving into the chilling case of Lizzie Borden. In 1892, Andrew and Abby Borden were brutally murdered in their Fall River home, and all eyes turn…
BONUS EPISODE 5: Short Stories
Ghosts, Goat Men & Grizzlies… Oh My! This chaotic and creepy bonus episode, Tayler and Colleen take you deep into the haunted hollers of the Appalachian mountains. From eerie tales of the legendary Goat Man to unsettling UFO abduction accou…
Episode 19: 300th Floor, Giggles Galore
In Episode 19, we’re back with a spine-tingling mix of paranormal chills and true crime thrills. Tayler takes us to the famously haunted Hotel Monte Vista in Flagstaff, Arizona—a historic hotspot with a long list of lingering spirits, unset…
BONUS EPISODE 4: Short Stories
In this chaotic and hilariously unhinged bonus episode, we dive into some of the spookiest and most unpredictable stories—pulled from the depths of Reddit and the corners of our own memories involving lightening strikes and booger demons. F…
Episode 18: Mystery Meat
This week on I've Got Something To Tell You, we’re diving deep into two chilling tales that will have you sleeping with the lights on. First, we explore the eerie and mysterious Elevator Game—an urban legend that blurs the lines between rea…
BONUS EPISODE 3: Short Stories
In this surprise bonus episode, we're diving headfirst into the strange and the unsettling. We're sharing a mix of Glitch in the Matrix stories and spine-tingling encounters with Black-Eyed Kids — some pulled straight from the eerie corners…
Episode 17: Freddy & The Tickle Factory
On this episode of I’ve Got Something To Tell You, we’re indulging in two mind-blowing tales that will give you chills in very different ways. First, we explore the haunting history of Rogers’ Chocolates, Canada’s oldest chocolatier. With a…
BONUS EPISODE 2: Short Stories
Surprise! We’re dropping a MINISODE that’s a little unhinged and a lot of fun. In this chaotic grab bag of an episode, we read some wild Reddit tales, share short stories that have stuck with us over the years, and dive into a few completel…
Episode 16: Hag Attacks & Tiny Hats
Is that a shadow in the corner of your eye... or the Hat Man coming to say hello? This week, we’re diving into the eerie world of Shadow People (yes, including the infamous Hat Man) and the terrifying true story of Robert Hansen, Alaska’s “…
Episode 15: Talkin with T-Dogg ft. T-Dawg
In this chilling episode of I’ve Got Something To Tell You, we delve into the infamous case of Jodi Arias and the tragic 2008 death of Travis Alexander that shocked the nation. We’ll explore the twisted love story, the events surrounding th…