Ep.25 Fan Request: The Circleville Letters, Ohio's Most Terrifying Unsolved Mystery

Listener Discretion is advised. Dive deep into the chilling true story of the Circleville Letters - one of Ohio’s most disturbing unsolved mysteries. For nearly 20 years, anonymous letters terrorized the small town of Circleville, Ohio, exposing dark secrets, threatening lives, and tearing apart a community.This comprehensive investigation covers the mysterious death of Ron Gillispie, the shocking booby trap that nearly killed school bus driver Mary Gillispie, and the controversial conviction of Paul Freshour - who may have been wrongly imprisoned while the real letter writer remained free. Explore the twisted tale of anonymous harassment, small-town paranoia, and a case that remains unsolved to this day.**What We’ll Cover:**- The complete timeline of the Circleville Letters from 1976-1994- Details of Ron Gillispie’s suspicious death in 1977- How the booby trap nearly killed Mary Gillispie in 1983- Why Paul Freshour’s conviction is controversial- Evidence the letters continued while Freshour was in prison- Top suspects and theories in this unsolved case- Why this case remains one of America’s strangest mysteriesREFERENCES & RESOURCES Primary Sources**CBS News / 48 Hours**- “The Circleville Letters: You’ve Got Hate Mail” (May 2024)- “Has the Anonymous Author of the Infamous Circleville Letters Been Unmasked?” (May 2024)- Erin Moriarty investigation and interviews- Crime Junkie Podcast- “INFAMOUS: Circleville Letters” episode (January 2025)- Whatever Remains Podcast**- Host: Marie Mayhew- Comprehensive multi-episode series on the Circleville LettersSecondary Sources**All That’s Interesting**- “Inside The Eerie Mystery Of The Circleville Letters That Terrorized An Ohio Town For Nearly 20 Years” (2025)**Columbus Navigator**- “Small Town, Big Secrets: The Chilling Circleville Letter Mystery That Stunned Ohio” (October 2024)**Mental Floss**- “Unknown Sender: The Mystery of the Circleville Letters” (2021)**Unsolved Mysteries Wiki**- Detailed case documentation and episode information**Vocal Media / Criminal**- Multiple investigative articles on the caseCourt Documents & Official Records- State of Ohio v. Paul L. Freshour (1983) - Pickaway County Common Pleas Court- Ohio Bureau of Criminal Investigation reports- Pickaway County Sheriff’s Department records- Ron Gillispie death investigation filesAdditional Resources**Books:**- “The Circleville Letters: A True Story of Small-Town Terror” by Erin Moriarty (2023)**TV/Media:**- Unsolved Mysteries (Season 7, Episode 6, 1993)- 48 Hours on Paramount+ - “The Circleville Letters” For More InformationVisit the Pickaway County Sheriff’s Office or Ohio Bureau of Criminal Investigation for official case information. This case remains unsolved and tips are still accepted.**Case Status:** Unsolved  **Location:** Circleville, Pickaway County, Ohio  **Time Period:** 1976-1994  **Victim:** Multiple residents of Circleville, Ohio  **Convicted:** Paul Freshour (attempted murder only, 1984)*All information presented is based on publicly available sources, court records, and investigative journalism. No claims are made regarding the guilt or innocence of any individuals mentioned.*See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#