A Date With Dateline
Kimberly and Katie are professional true crime TV experts with no formal training but evidence lockers filled with snark and uninformed opinions. Katie watches Dateline in hopes to learn how to prevent her new husband from murdering her for the life insurance money, and Kimberly watches so she’ll know what to say when Keith Morrison interviews her about her best friend Katie’s murder.
Episodes
Internal Affairs S.24 Ep.14
The One With The Tale of Two Women and a man called Jerkier. AKA INTERNAL AFFAIRS! Official Description from NBCU: When a graduate student is shot dead outside of her North Carolina home, a 911 caller leads detectives to believe the victi…
The Mystery on Bridle Path S.23 Ep.27
The One With Mr. 603, Jail Vent Rumors, and The ah HA Moment AKA The Mystery on Bridle Path! Official Description from NBCU: The unbelievable murder of Carol Kennedy, a popular college professor, artist and mother. Keith Morrison reports…
The Informant S.25 Ep.46
It’s The One With The Murder Van, AKA THE INFORMANT! Official Description from NBCU: A woman's story about an abduction and murder helps reopen a decades-old case that has weighed heavy on a New York town. Dennis Murphy reports. This ep…
The Family Secret S.19 Ep.26
We’ve had Family Affair. We’ve had Buried Secrets. We’ve even had Family Secrets. But this is THE FAMILY SECRET. It’s a classic Dateline hosted by Baby Keith, featuring one of the worst Idaho mothers we’ve seen on Dateline (second perhaps o…
The Gilgo Beach Killer: House of Secrets Ep.3
In the conclusion of the 3 part series THE GILGO BEACH KILLER: HOUSE OF SECRETS from Peacock (and 50 Cent?!) Katie and Jake return to the Rex Heuerman case one last time. In episode 3 "The Good Wife" a second serial killer has decided to en…
KAREN READ ALL ABOUT IT: Center of the Storm S.33 Ep.67
The verdict is in! And the jury of public opinion has spoken on the topic of these highly publicized trials. They have confirmed that people will never be done seeking justice for Boston police officer John O'Keefe and therefore we are goin…
The Gilgo Beach Killer: House of Secrets Ep.2
Dateline is on somewhere on a beach building sandcastles on their summer break. So, Jake joins Katie to talk about the exact opposite of that sunny summer activity. It's the halfway point in discussing the new PEACOCK limited series THE GIL…
The Gilgo Beach Killer: House of Secrets Ep.1
Dateline is on summer break. So, Jake joins Katie for a couple of cheat dates on a new PEACOCK limited series (that's not Dateline) about a very big case with a looooong history. A Long Island history.... We will be delving into the world o…
Secrets of the Sliding Door S.33 Ep.27
In this recent Dateline episode- Mr. Keith Morrison is telling us the story of Ms. Pumpkin, her relationship with Mr. Liar McPantsafire, and the secrets of a married teacher on Staten Island that may have lead to murder. When beloved Disney…
The Pin at Apartment 210 S.33 Ep.24
Calling all Blayniacs! Join host Blayne Alexander for a case that asks the question, “How far would you go for your family”? When a young woman goes missing during Thanksgiving, her family goes FAR to figure out what happened to her and to …
The Terrible Night on King Road S.33 Ep.28
It’s the story we all know, except that it’s not! Dateline and Our Leaning King Keith are bringing us never before heard, brand new elements of the horrific story of the four Idaho students killed in 2022! We’ve got the most awkward pool pa…
Murder in MInot S.33 Ep.26
Our new correspondent Blayne Alexander is back, and even though she doesn’t have an official nickname yet, we are for sure proud Blayniacs! When a beloved young college student is killed, there are a surprising number of suspects: The maint…
The Devil's in the Details S.33 Ep.25
West Virginia, mountain mama, take me home to where a good looking young couple sells guns and pills to the government, scams their friends and family out of millions of dollars, and then one of them get murdered. Thank goodness our Queen A…
Listen Now: Death County, PA
Lamont Jones leaves Dauphin County Prison for the last time, a free man ready to move on with his life. But when his young cousin dies in that same jail, he learns that this is not the only mysterious death that has plagued Dauphin County P…
Part of the Plan S.32 Ep.14
Our Lean(ing) King is heading to Sin City! Vegas is filled with drugs. Sex. Cirque du Soleil. What happens in Vegas stays in Vegas. Except when it’s murder. Murder stays there. When a military man is killed in his own home, Keith and some v…
The Widow of Woodland Hills S.33 Ep.23
When a successful and beloved celebrity hairdresser is brutally murdered in his own backyard, it’s a case so twisted it could use detangler. And there’s only one man that’s stylish enough to walk us through it. A man whose hankies are known…
Deadly Obsession S.33 Ep.21
The Fourth of July is for apple pie, parades, and drunken fools losing finger tips from fireworks. Unless this is Dateline, in which case it’s for murder, casino surveillance footage, bag of wieners boyfriends, AutoZone gas cans, astronaut…
Cheat Date with HULU: Little Miss Innocent
Little Miss Innocent: Passion. Poison. Prison. Kimberly. Katie. Uneducated. Opinions. Judgmental. Chiropractor. Messy. Car. Messy. Case. Anonymous. Letter. Colchicine. Email. Framing. Affair. Screenshots. Receipts. Timeline. Sister. Opinion…
Poison Twist S.33 Ep.20
It’s the case we last covered in 2017, this time with better microphones but no more knowledge, insight, or decisions about this truly baffling case. When a seemingly beloved chiropractor is poisoned with an extreme dose of gout medicine, t…
Deadly Entanglement S.33 Ep.19
If Dateline has taught us one thing, it’s that love triangles are the most dangerous kind of triangles. But what about love quads and love pentagrams? What happens when one woman weaves a web of love and lust, entangling others, culminating…
Lori Vallow Daybell: The Jailhouse Interview S.33 Ep.18
It’s the interview that the whole world was waiting for, the interview that the whole world was watching with mouths agape until they threw their tv or phone against the wall in frustration. The interview where we learned that Keith Morriso…
The Haunted House Confession S.33 Ep.17
Imagine the scariest most decrepit farmhouse in the world. No, scarier. Now add demon snakes, haunted Victorian dolls with missing eyes singing off key lullabies to you, and the witch from Hansel and Gretel but her face is on fire and she w…
A Walk Through The Woods S.33 Ep.16
Dateline and Andrea Canning are taking us over a rickety old bridge and through the woods where two lively teenagers had their lives cut short in a horrific way. Does this sound like the type of episode K and K would normally cover? No, it’…
The Rise and Fall of Oscar Pistorius S.28 Ep.45
Let me ask you something… How’re you fixed for Dateline episodes with a special guest host? Well, have we got a deal for you today! Jake is back to chat about THE RISE AND FALL OF OSCAR PISTORIUS Season 28 Episode 45 . It’s a case that rece…
Under the Bay Bridge S.33 Ep.14
It’s a story you might’ve heard before, but not from Dateline and the beloved pocket square squire Josh Mankiewicz! In the tech world of Silicon Valley, bitcoin rules and computer viruses drool. When a beloved tech innovator is murdered, ev…
The Devil Wore White S.33 Ep.13
It’s the mother son crime duo whose killing spree spanned from coast to coast and grabbed the world’s attention… except Kimberly and Katie, apparently. We somehow missed this WILD story but we were so excited to get to hear it for the first…
Death Trap S.27 Ep.4 - The Revisit
Kimberly and Katie have dug into the archives to revisit the classic-est of all the classic Dateline episodes we’ve ever covered. This episode truly has everything: Pizza bomb. Casual lollipoping. Escape room fail. JJ the Scapegoat. Terrifi…
A Little Patch of Perfect S.33 Ep.11
Dateline's Leaning Daddy Keith Morrison returns with a case in Georgia that plays out like a southern Agatha Christie novel! When a man known as Big Daddy is found tragically dead in a burn pit, there are five suspects, and they are all his…
Manner of Death S.22 Ep.1
We’re dipping back into the vault for a classic Dateline that proves for the thousandth time that you should never accept a beverage from your spouse. Never. Just get your own beverage. You’ll get in a few more steps walking to the fridge a…
The Plan S.28 Ep.3
It’s 2025! And what better way to start the new year than with a very special Dateline Dennisode! And Dennis Murphy is in highest gumshoe detective form in this episode from Season 28 THE PLAN. He is talking us through the absolute worst cr…
Special Guest: Josh Mankiewicz on DEADLY MIRAGE Podcast
It’s the man, the myth, the MANK! Josh Mankiewicz swings by the streamyard studio to chat about his latest incredible podcast with Dateline- DEADLY MIRAGE. And the story is a little familiar.. .involving a particular wolfpack in place calle…
The Man of Many Faces S.33 Ep.10
It’s the update you’ve been waiting for. The update you’ve been asking for. The update you’ve been holding your breath for! It’s THE MAN OF MANY FACES! The incomparable Andrea Canning is taking us on a journey around the world to find out i…
Without a Trace S.24 Ep.7
In this throwback Dateline episode from 2015 Andrea Canning heads to a mysterious place called the Quad Cities where a missing persons report has turned into a tragic murder and nothing is as it seems. Including the fact that the Quad Citie…
Deadly Dance S.33 Ep.8
In DEADLY DANCE, Andrea Canning is en pointe, as always, as she reports on the possible poisoning, self defense shooting, Ben Carson fundraiser of a complicated case known as The Black Swan Murder Trial. Yes. That case that keeps popping up…
Listen Now - Hollywood & Crime: The Cotton Club Murder
On June 10th, 1983, the decomposing body of a well-dressed man was found in a desolate canyon near Los Angeles. John Doe #94would soon be identified as missing variety show producer Roy Radin. He'd last been seen after meeting with a myster…
The Killer Among Them S.33 Ep.9
Come on, ride the train right back to 1996, where the technology was primitive and the cars were ooooddd looking, but the music was poppin’ and the fashion was… something special. When a successful Atlanta entrepreneur is found murdered in …
Deadly Omission S.33 Ep.5
In this episode, Dateline has commissioned the incomparable Andrea Canning for a long and twisted story with a DEADLY OMISSION! It’s a case involving a man who played too good a game of Peek A Boo and somehow lost two wives, through no faul…
The Menendez Brothers Chance at Freedom S.33 Ep.7
We were hoping for a fun light episode this week, maybe a good heist story or a con man gets his comeuppance after a long FBI cat and mouse. And Dateline has answered our prayers with THE MENENDEZ BROTHERS: A CHANCE AT FREEDOM! Here is the …
After the Halloween Party S.33 Ep.6
Need a distraction from, oh you know, nothing whatsoever, nothing’s happening right now! Join KImberly and Katie for a post Halloween tale told the only way Dateline can. When a woman disappears AFTER THE HALLOWEEN PARTY, her small town is …
The Night of the Noreaster-PART TWO S.33 Ep.4
Have you been Karen Read(ing) All About It? If you haven’t been living and breathing this case because you are more of a Kimberly and not a Katie, then Dateline has got you covered! And if you HAVE been obsessing over this case, we’ve got y…