The Girl in the Pond

The Girl in the Pond

Host: Times Union

In the summer of 1908, America was transfixed by the murder of a woman found floating in a country pond in upstate New York. The mystery of a young beauty brutally killed became an instant sensation, splashed across the front page of the country’s newspapers. Was she killed by a spurned lover? Was she leading a secret double life outside of her station as a governess to the wealthy residents of Troy, New York? Did she know too many secrets?  The murder went unsolved, and after about three weeks, the girl in the pond was all but forgotten. More than a ce...

Episodes

5. The Third Degree and the Fourth Estate
01October 07, 2025 4:00am

5. The Third Degree and the Fourth Estate

In 1908, the idea of law enforcement as an investigatory body hadn’t quite caught on. Police forces were more brute squad than Sherlock Holmes. Corruption among the ranks of law and order was rampant, and criminal confessions were often coe…

'The Last Rose of Summer’
02September 30, 2025 4:00am

'The Last Rose of Summer’

The theme song for “The Girl in the Pond” is a modernized rendition of one of the most popular songs of 1908. The original words are a poem by Irish writer Sir Thomas Moore, set to a melody by Irish composer Sir John Andrew Stevenson. This …

4. Family Ties
03September 23, 2025 4:00am

4. Family Ties

As the investigation into Hazel Drew’s murder began in July of 1908, investigators ran into roadblocks in the form of her family members, who either didn’t know, or would not reveal information about her life. And it may have been the key t…

3. Come to Troy
04September 16, 2025 4:00am

3. Come to Troy

The upstate New York city where Hazel Drew was living and working was a booming center of industry at the Eastern Terminus of the Erie Canal in the early 20th century. But it was also a roiling stew of political corruption and resistance to…

2. Pond Mystery
05September 09, 2025 4:00am

2. Pond Mystery

A peek back into the Times Union newspaper archives reveals a wealth of information about the investigation into Hazel Drew’s murder in the summer of 1908. But no official records remain, and all the players, from investigators to potential…

1. Ghost Stories
06September 02, 2025 4:00amExplicit

1. Ghost Stories

Stories about a ghostly young woman appearing in and around Sand Lake, New York, have persisted for generations. Those who tell the stories, whether they’ve seen the specter themselves or heard it secondhand, believe it’s the ghost of Hazel…

Trailer: The Girl in the Pond
07August 12, 2025 8:34am

Trailer: The Girl in the Pond

In the summer of 1908, America was transfixed by the murder of a woman found floating in a country pond in upstate New York. Was this young beauty killed by a spurned lover? Was she leading a secret double life outside of her station as a g…