LOVE MURDER
Jessie Pray and Andie Cassette team up each week to tell stories of love and relationships gone fatally wrong. This show is all about seemingly normal people driven to terrible madness by passion and rage. Hang out with your new best friends each week to discover how someone can go from sweet to murderous in the blink of an eye, and to hear all the ways murder can give love a real bad name.
Episodes
The Birch Drive Tragedy [Current Affairs]
On an ordinary October evening in Fort Pierce, Florida, a missed call turned into a family’s worst nightmare. When 60-year-old Bonnie Tietgens finally reached her son, she confessed to killing his father, William Tietgens Jr. What followed …
Nightmare on Main Street: The Markle Family Murders
A stormy night, a black out and a mysterious phone call lead the police to an eerie house on a hill containing the bodies of an entire family. All of this, plus a connection to The Exorcist, feels like the setup to a particularly scary movi…
Introducing BURIED: Inside the John Wayne Gacy Investigation
Jessie and Andie are thrilled to share a new podcast. BURIED: Inside the John Wayne Gacy Investigation is a true-crime podcast featuring never-before-heard recordings of John Wayne Gacy and new admissions from the detectives who investigate…
Major League Monster: Gary Spohr, Wendy Wood and Dan Serafini
When a senior married couple falls victim to a deadly home invasion, the police search for answers from the family - including an adult daughter in a complicated marriage to a former professional athlete.Sources:1. Bandur, Michelle. “Dan Se…
Betrayal in Inkster: The London Thomas Story [Current Affairs]
In this episode of Current Affairs, the tragic disappearance and murder of 17-year-old London Thomas in Inkster, Michigan is explored. What began as a frantic three-week search ended in a horrific discovery, revealing a story of betrayal th…
The Disappearance of Nick Howard: Accident, Hoax or Murder?
When an 18-year old boy goes missing, police and family are left wondering: was it an accident, a hoax, or was he the victim of foul play? Along the way, the authorities would discover a nefarious obsession that began years before Nick was …
The Mexico City Murders: B-King and Regio Clown [Current Affairs]
On September 14th, 2025, Colombian urban artist Bayron “B-King” Sánchez and DJ Jorge “Regio Clown” Herrera performed in Mexico City. Two days later, they vanished. Their bodies were discovered on September 22nd, tortured, dismembered, and a…
Au Pair Nightmare: Sophie Lionnet, Sabrina Kouider and Ouissem Medouni
A troubled single mother ends up at the center of a lopsided love triangle between a longtime on-again/off-again boyfriend and a famous music producer. As she descends into madness, an innocent young French au pair ends up caught in her web…
A Killing in Connecticut: Jennifer Farber Dulos and Fotis Dulos
When a beautiful, talented and wealthy mother of five disappears in an upscale Connecticut suburb, suspicion is cast upon her husband and his girlfriend.Sources:Murder in the Dollhouse: The Jennifer Dulos Story by Rich CohenVanished in New …
The Murder of Celeste Rivas Hernandez [Current Affiars]
In this Current Affairs episode of Love Murder, Jessie and Andie cover the tragic case of 15-year-old Celeste Rivas Hernandez. Reported missing from Lake Elsinore, California in 2024, Celeste’s remains were discovered in September 2025 in t…
Malevolent Manipulations: The Murder of Dianne Hood
When a young mother is gunned down outside of a Lupus support group, police initially suspect a robbery gone wrong. After they discover a unique murder weapon, they are able to follow the deadly breadcrumbs back to an illicit affair.Sources…
Introducing: CRIMES OF…
Power. Fame. Obsession. Betrayal. These are more than headlines. They are the forces behind some of the most unforgettable crimes in history. Crimes Of... is a weekly true crime anthology series, hosted by Sabrina Deana-Roga and Corinne Vie…
The Matriarch Mastermind: Donna Adelson's Downfall [Current Affairs]
In this episode of Current Affairs, we delve into the final chapter of the Dan Markel murder-for-hire saga, focusing on the recent conviction of Donna Adelson. Discover how the 75-year-old "matriarch mastermind" orchestrated the murder of h…
Brazilian Betrayal: Marcos Matsunaga and Elize AraĂşjo Kitano Matsunaga
In 2012, inside a quiet luxury apartment in Sao Paulo, a couple sat down to confront their marital trust issues. What began as a tense conversation between husband and wife quickly spiraled into violence and horror and what followed left an…
Sin City Secrets: Bruce Weinstein & Amy DeChant
When a beloved bookie disappears from his Las Vegas home, police believe that he may have been killed for being a police informant. However, when not one but two bodies are found buried in the desert, suspicion is cast upon his love life.So…
Dentists Gone Wild: David and Clara Harris
Infidelity and insecurity plague the otherwise charmed marriage between a dentist and orthodontist in early 2000's Houston, Texas. When tensions and betrayals reach an all-time fever pitch, someone ends up murdered.Long, Steven. Out of Cont…
Nightmare on Nantucket: Beth Lochtefeld and Tom Toolan
A Labor Day meet-cute on Nantucket develops into a dreamy whirlwind romance, and then, just as quickly, a nightmare.McDonald, Brian. Safe Harbor. Macmillan, 2007.“23 Knife Wounds in Nantucket Murder.” ABC News, 12 June 2007, https://abcnews…
The Architect, the Songbird, and the Chauffeur: The Rattenbury Scandal
Lust, lies, adultery, wealth, cocaine and cocktails abound in this Jazz Age love triangle episode between a famous architect, his loving wife, and their teenage chauffeur.Sources:Deadly Triangle: The Famous Architect, His Wife, Their Chauff…
The Venier Family Murder Plot [Current Affairs]
Join Jessie and Andie on Current Affairs for the shocking story of Lorena Venier and Mailyn Castro Monsalvo, a mother-in-law and daughter-in-law who conspired to kill and dismember Alessandro Venier. Uncover the disturbing details of Alessa…
Mansion Murders and Mayhem: The Many Victims of Marjorie Congdon
Marjorie Congdon was raised in the lap of luxury at the famous Glensheen Mansion by her loving adoptive mother Elizabeth. But despite having everything, Marjorie always wanted more. Her incredible greed would lead to a shocking number of ar…
Music and Murder: Lana Clarkson and Phil Spector
When a beautiful actress accompanies a legendary music producer home, a fatal tragedy occurs. The survivor has one story while witnesses and eventually the state of California have a different one.1. “Lana Clarkson (1962-2003) - Find a Grav…
Burned in Barcelona: The Rosa Peral Affair
A Barcelona police officer is found burned in the trunk of his own car. His girlfriend, Rosa Peral, is quickly arrested. But was she a cold-blooded killer or a scapegoat in a sensational love triangle? As the media frenzy explodes, the case…
Tainted Love: Michael & Danielle Redlick
A long-time couple in Winter Park, Florida seem to have it all: 15 years of marriage, a beautiful home and two incredible children. When it all comes to a murderous end amid a violent altercation, dangerous secrets as well as a seriously mu…
The Betrayal of Matthew Restelli [Current Affairs]
This episode unravels the chilling murder of Matthew Restelli, who was ambushed and killed by his wife, her mother, and her brother. Discover how a reconciliation attempt turned into a high-tech death trap, meticulously planned with hidden …
Sex and Murder on the Beach: Renee and Brent Poole
A young couple is celebrating their third wedding anniversary in romantic fashion on Myrtle Beach when tragedy strikes. Was it a robbery gone wrong or cold-blooded murder?Sources:Dance of Death by Dale HudsonScorned Love Kills S1E3Bonnie’s …
The Tragic Disappearance of Marissa DiNapoli
In this episode of Current Affairs, we delve into the heartbreaking case of Marissa DiNapoli, an 18-year-old whose life was cut short in Morgan Hill, California. Her ex-boyfriend, Martin Mendoza, is now the prime suspect in what police are …
Spy vs. Spy: Gene and Margo Bennett
A marriage between FBI agents results in fraud and affairs. But when they try to get divorced, the problems escalate to perjury, kidnapping, rape, attempted murder, and a violent shootout in a church.Sources:1. Rother, Caitlin, and John Hes…
The Extraordinary Life and Tragic Murder of Sam Cooke
On this episode, Jessie brings the story of the extraordinary life and tragic death of musical genius, activist and visionary Sam Cooke. This Episode Brought To You By:Shopify - The Platform Commerce is Built On - $1 per month trial https:…
The Coroner Affair Murder [Current Affairs]
On October 2nd, 2020, Gregory Rice vanished. Over a month later, his tarp-wrapped body was discovered, revealing a sensational murder case. At its heart was Meagan Jackson, Rice's ex and a body transporter, accused of orchestrating his murd…
Reine of Terror: Melvin Reine, Wanda Medeiros Reine, and Shirley Souza Reine
Cape Cod, Massachusetts in the summertime is nothing short of picturesque, however in this episode, it’s the backdrop for no less than four murders, one attempted murder of a cop and countless arsons. The culprit, known as the “Falmouth Fox…
Karen Read Found NOT GUILTY in Second Trial [Current Affairs]
Jessie and Andie recap Karen Read’s 2025 retrial, tracing the case from Officer John O’Keefe’s death to Read’s acquittal on homicide charges and lone conviction for OUI. The episode details key differences from the 2024 mistrial, the effect…
The Unsettling Murder of Fabio Sementilli
What first appeared to be a simple knock-knock burglary-gone-wrong quickly unraveled into a cold-blooded murder that shocked everyone. As an affair came to light and layers of deception were peeled away, however, suspicion began to settle o…
Love Murder and Going West Are Going on Tour!
In September, we're going on our first-ever tour! Find us in Denver, Dallas, Atlanta, Boston, and Chicago alongside headliners Going West for five mysteriously fun evenings! We really hope to expand this tour, so get your tickets THIS WEEK!…
The Torrey Moore Double Murder Case [Current Affairs]
When detectives tracked down Torrey Moore for a senseless murder in a Maryland convenience store, they uncovered a far darker crime hidden behind closed doors: the decomposing body of his pregnant girlfriend, Denise Middleton. This disturbi…
Sid & Nancy: A Punk Rock Tragedy
When punk rocker Sid Vicious and infamous groupie Nancy Spungen meet in 1970's London, sparks fly -- as does chaos. Within two years, both would be dead, becoming known as punk's tragic Romeo & Juliet. But do we know what really happened th…
Teenage Love Spiral: Stacey Hanna, Kelly Gibbs, Domica Winckler, Tracy Bitner
A group of teenage lesbians finds comfort, support and even love with one another in late 90's Richmond, Virginia. The harmonious environment is disturbed however when love triangles emerge, lies blend with truth and friendships turn deadly…
The Execution and Desert Burial of Nancy LeFleur [Current Affairs]
When Nancy LeFleur vanished in early 2024, few realized the dark reality behind her disappearance. After months of controlling abuse and living on the run, Nancy was executed by her husband, Shaun LeFleur, in the isolated deserts of New Mex…
The Triple Murder at Malabar Farm
When three members of a family die mysteriously in 1896, suspicion turns on the surviving member and her shocking motivation.Sources:The Ceely Rose Murders at Malabar Farm by Mark Sebastian JordanThis Week's Episode is Brought To You By:Fas…
The Deadly Romance of Kathleen McLean and Dr. Harry Tuerk [Current Affairs]
Kathleen McLean, a devoted mother of three, thought she'd found love with prominent surgeon Dr. Ingolf "Harry" Tuerk. But their whirlwind romance quickly turned dangerous, descending into violence and control. Despite efforts to escape, Kat…
Wicked Widower: Emelita, Sharon and Jack Reeves
When a beautiful young wife goes missing, police take a closer look at her older husband's past relationships.Sources: 1. Dowling, Paul. Forensic Files. 2002.2. “Emelita Villa Reeves (1968-1994) - Find a Grave Memorial.” Find a Grave - Mill…